Game Thread: WW LXXXVI - The Halls of Mandos - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Nogrod · 01-26-2011, 06:28 PM

Shasta - first overabundant banter, then being totally wrong... he's a clever man so he can't be just erring here?
Glirdan - only a few early banters...
A Little Green - not too much participation but has posted on substance unlike some others on this list.
elronds_daughter - one post, puzzlingly non-commitant looking at the fact that she actually said something.
Mänwe - one post, one sentence, saying nothing.
Loslote - overdoing the banter...
Nessa - Not so bad Mith let's us understand, if she meant that the wolves don't know whether they killed a gifted, an ordo or a cobbler, but quite minimal contributions to say it minimalistically.
Sally - posted when there was actually discussion going on but only bantered (except suspecting Lottie for bantering with Shasta - why not the other way around?).
Fea one post now, neutralish.

No posts so far, no vote from me on D1
Blind Guardian
Wilwa

In a game where we need to read everything from what others say without a chance to check afterwards for sure, I do think lynching the quieter ones - those not giving up anything - is a better choice. Later on when we have some real feelings / arguments of those who meddle with the game a lot more, or have a chance there will be some info coming from Mandos, then we should start lynching the more in the middle of the things -players.

So my vote is going to someone on the list above.

A cigarette to think about it and then to sleep.

EDIT X'd with a few... heh seemingly also Shasta's vote...

01-26-2011, 06:28 PM	#32
Nogrod Flame of the Ainulindalë Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: Wearing rat's coat, crowskin, crossed staves in a field behaving as the wind behaves Posts: 9,308	Shasta - first overabundant banter, then being totally wrong... he's a clever man so he can't be just erring here? Glirdan - only a few early banters... A Little Green - not too much participation but has posted on substance unlike some others on this list. elronds_daughter - one post, puzzlingly non-commitant looking at the fact that she actually said something. Mänwe - one post, one sentence, saying nothing. Loslote - overdoing the banter... Nessa - Not so bad Mith let's us understand, if she meant that the wolves don't know whether they killed a gifted, an ordo or a cobbler, but quite minimal contributions to say it minimalistically. Sally - posted when there was actually discussion going on but only bantered (except suspecting Lottie for bantering with Shasta - why not the other way around?). Fea one post now, neutralish. No posts so far, no vote from me on D1 Blind Guardian Wilwa In a game where we need to read everything from what others say without a chance to check afterwards for sure, I do think lynching the quieter ones - those not giving up anything - is a better choice. Later on when we have some real feelings / arguments of those who meddle with the game a lot more, or have a chance there will be some info coming from Mandos, then we should start lynching the more in the middle of the things -players. So my vote is going to someone on the list above. A cigarette to think about it and then to sleep. EDIT X'd with a few... heh seemingly also Shasta's vote... __________________ Upon the hearth the fire is red Beneath the roof there is a bed; But not yet weary are our feet...