WW LXXIX: Fall From Olympus

[Macalaure]

We should force Nog to go to bed. (Yes, he just voted, but we all know that that doesn't mean anything.) He's doesn't seem to be himself, but he doesn't seem like Wolf-Nog either - more like jetlag-Nog.
The whole hell/Hades debate with all the trying-to-not-imply-swearing is hilarious!

Greenie - toMorrow we're giving your warm, soft side a turn, ok?

I don't really understand what Shasta's reasons for voting Nogrod are. "His case is a big steaming bucket of double-, triple-, and quadruple-bluffing" sounds weird.

Eonwe, may I paraphrase your case against me as "Mac looks really, really good actually but there are a few far-fetched things that might mean he could be a wolf"? Also, you end your case against me with "He needs to be watched" and then put me in the highest "Evil" category. Consistency that is not.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

There was this incredible "taming of Mac" that took place. I had totally forgotten it. What happened? I mean the to and fro between Mac and tp ending in the sugariest ending I've seen in a while...

"The Taming of the Mac"? Somebody else already did that job.
Anyway, I think you're interpreting much more drama into it than there was. Phantom tested me a little, I joked about it, then a few people ran away with it, I clarified it (a little annoyed), phantom bought my explanation, peace, love, happiness.
(Except for poor Shasta, who based his accusations on it.)

Originally Posted by Shasta

Now there are two clear "buts" involved.

Third but: The only other time Boro mentions Eonwe he does so quite half-heartedly. Doesn't fit if he was his dream and found evil. He would have encouraged people's suspicions, at least subtly.
You're really too fixated on Eonwe's guilt.