WW LXXIX: Fall From Olympus

[Inziladun]

Hmm. A very busy RL day, and an insane amount of posting here. I can't recall ever seeing anything like this number of posts by Day 2! It's quite a lot to read through, but I think I've pretty well caught up.

Seems as if Nog, tp, Rikae, Nerwen, and to a lesser extent, Mac have been most in the spotlight toDay.

Of those, let's see...

Rikae I think I'm surprisingly all right with, for the time being.

Mac: Ehhh.....I still don't trust him enough to put him in the clear, but I won't be voting for him toDay.

tp: It's been a long time since I've played with him, and the only trustworthy phantom is a deceased phantom , but he doesn't seem evil right now.

Nerwen: Every time I trust her it seems to bite me, and every time I suspect her she seems to be innocent. I can't really find fault with her though. I don't remember who said it, but I agree that it's hard to see her being so blatant with a Hades hint, even if she did think she might have the cover of eveyone else speaking similarly. I want to believe her that it was a throwaway remark.

And Nog? I don't remember innocent Nog being so single-minded as he's been toDay. Usually he makes such a fuss of suspecting submarines, and not wanting to focus too narrowly on any particular person, but that hasn't been the case toDay. He seems to have just kept hammering away at the same points.

Which brings me to:

Originally Posted by autume98

I haven't gone through all the thread yet, but I do want to post my reasoning for the reason I voted BG yesterday since I've noticed a few concerns.

The reason I didn't vote for Mac yesterday is simply because I wanted to keep Eonwe around for a little bit longer. At the time Eonwe was also being looked at being lynched. At the time specualation was that he may be Dionysis, and I wasn't ready to lynch him yesterDay. I felt like we should keep him around and in order to do that I had to vote for BG. If I would've had enough people on my side I would've voted for Mac.

Your indications didn't seem to be that you were still ready to vote Mac. You pretty much just started agreeing with him, as if you hadn't said he was your top suspect shortly before. You even used his criticism of mine and Wilwa's votes for BG as reasons to suspect us.
Also, at the time you voted, BG had 5 votes, and Eönwë had 4. But you had to "save" him?

Originally Posted by Nogrod

Looking at Boro's posting the only believable seer hint - let's say unambiguos - is the one concerning Eonwë being -4 damage to us innocents. THat's actually quite boldly said if the scale has been made with innocent dying being between +1-10.

That bothers me too. I don't understand why Boro said that, if he didn't know something. It's the most concrete thing I saw that could have pointed to one of his dreams. But why wasn't he more overt about suspecting Eönwë, if he was ready to give him a "Neg 4"?

Hmm. Nog, who I rather suspect through his own words and his possible link to my top suspect, tum, has voted Eönwë. Not really a big surprise, but it puts me in a bit of a bind.
I want to lynch tum. But she did say that she wanted to protect Eönwë yesterDay, so his lynch could tell me something about her. Then again, so could Nog's.

*sigh*

x/d with Mac and Wilwa