T-I-G LVI: Panic at the Prancing Pony

[Thinlómien]

I think Rune's and Fea's "explanations" look rather innocent.

I don't think Rune is very suspicious at any rate, if he and Fea were fellows, would he really defend her so openly? I doubt it. Ok, the possibility remains that he was trying to buddy up innocent Fea or prepared to take her down with him in case he's going to die, but why would he do something so eyebrow-raising to get such a small and unsure gain? It does not make sense and therefore the option that seems reasonable to me is that he's innocent and simply wants to keep Fea around. (Of course, he could be a wraith who just wants to keep Fea around... but I doubt a wraith would be so reckless.) Besides, like I've said before, his aggressiveness on Day1 looks rather innocent. I would not be worried about him.

As for Fea... a tougher nut to crack. But what Mac says about her makes sense. I would be willing to give her the benefit of doubt (for toDay at least). I think what Mac says as for her being a wraith solidifies my view of her as a non-wraith, but I'm not convinced of his reasoning why she's not Ferny. Who says the wraiths know Ferny's identity?

But Lari and Mira, they are not as easily exonerated. I would not be surprised at all if one of them voted Durelin yesterDay just to cast an easy vote, not fully comprehending the situation, or making a vote people could excuse for them by saying they were saving their RL friend. Lari seems more suspicious to me of these since like it has been pointed out, her explanations don't quite hold water...

Okay, now I will write a post commenting other stuff, hopefully discussing something else than the Dury-wagon...

[Aganzir]

Originally Posted by Mac

Rune's desire to save Fea is out of proportion.

Yes that's true but it might also be because he enjoys playing with Fea so much. However there wasn't much of a threat that she'd be lynched. Also, if Rune was a wraith, would he try to save an evil Fea so obviously?

Originally Posted by Brinn

But what makes you so sure the wraiths didn't think he was Frodo?

What reason would they have had to think so?
This looks a bit like a wolfish Brinn had slipped something from their nightly discussion.

Originally Posted by Mac

Maybe he was killed to give us something to talk about and confuse us. At least that's what I enjoy doing when I'm a wolf.

And who's the most eager to talk about his death?

Originally Posted by Legate

whether Frodo should be silent or try to give hints about his identity.

Hey I didn't say xe should give hints about xyr identity, I just said xe might do so with plans to get turned into a wraith.
And yes, it might look suspicious if I disagreed with everyone else, but I'd do it if I thought I was right. I had been thinking of Frodo just as a cursed role who wants to become a wolf but then people brought up good points about xem being on our side at least in the beginning.

Greenie's list is creepy because it could have been written by me.

Originally Posted by Lommy

Well but once we've had the quarrel, we tend to be able to be civil to each other, so I'm not going to ignore you, at least (even if it means another quarrel, I think I will be able to stay calm-ish)...

It was a response to your comment that we shouldn't play werewolf together, at least this way. It wasn't intended to include this game in particular.

I think Rikae's comments on Fea make the most sense thus far and garr I don't want to trust Rikae all the time! Anyway it wouldn't be that difficult for an evil Fea to talk herself out of the situation, which means that if she's to be lynched she should be lynched sooner rather than later.

I could go through Mira's posts now. And I should still write those papers, argh.