The Good and The Bad - a Quick Look at the Movies

[Macalaure]

Originally Posted by Matthew

I agree. I actually must recant what I said about this scene, I actually think it should be under the "BAD" category. Boromir's words with Frodo should have been much longer and closer to the text. Bean was good in the scene, but again he is not my Boromir.

I wouldn't put it into The Bad category, it's simply not bad enough compared to the company it would have there (like the drinking game! ). Maybe we need a, probably huge, Could Be Better category.