Bilbo´s treachery - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Ivriniel · 12-04-2015, 06:36 AM

I have some specific questions for Morthoron

1. Were you aware that the Hobbit had a pre-1937/8 variant as evidenced by CS Lewis's letter?
2. Were you aware about the state of the Lay of Leithian by 1933?
3. Were you aware that Tolkien's first adaption of LotR used the ***original*** Hobbit as its foundation.
4. Do you assert that the Prof didn't have ongoing anxiety and pressure from Allen and Unwin about publication deadlines (LotR), about despondency for repeated rejection of the Silarillion.
5. Were you aware that the Prof had a pre-Hobbit Silmarillion model?
6 The Devil's Number Do you assert that the 1933 version (typed and read by CS Lewis) or latter version was the one that Tolkien dissociates the ring from the Ring?

7. Did you known that Shelob ate the Silmarils? Or that Ungoliants wanted to eat the Silmarils, or do you assert that Earendil's refuse on Vingilot (what does he eat up there?) has Silmari 'glow' as he tosses out his bowel movements over Vingilot over Arda?

And Morthoron, I'm going to go back to the thread where I was accused of being a 'Troll', and after it, I received a PM pointing out that someone had been PM'd stating that someone else had gone too far.*

I don't remember if it was you who said 'I was a troll', but at the time, actually, I didn't even read it ahahahahah.

as I said, get a sense of humour and seriously, the funniest question: please respondS [Gollum] to number 7

Kind Regrds

[Edit]*names and stones and fixed up tomes, and words that do not break bones[/edit]

STAVROS

12-04-2015, 06:36 AM	#11
Ivriniel Shade of Carn Dûm Join Date: Feb 2014 Posts: 430	I have some specific questions for Morthoron 1. Were you aware that the Hobbit had a pre-1937/8 variant as evidenced by CS Lewis's letter? 2. Were you aware about the state of the Lay of Leithian by 1933? 3. Were you aware that Tolkien's first adaption of LotR used the *original* Hobbit as its foundation. 4. Do you assert that the Prof didn't have ongoing anxiety and pressure from Allen and Unwin about publication deadlines (LotR), about despondency for repeated rejection of the Silarillion. 5. Were you aware that the Prof had a pre-Hobbit Silmarillion model? 6 The Devil's Number Do you assert that the 1933 version (typed and read by CS Lewis) or latter version was the one that Tolkien dissociates the ring from the Ring? 7. Did you known that Shelob ate the Silmarils? Or that Ungoliants wanted to eat the Silmarils, or do you assert that Earendil's refuse on Vingilot (what does he eat up there?) has Silmari 'glow' as he tosses out his bowel movements over Vingilot over Arda? And Morthoron, I'm going to go back to the thread where I was accused of being a 'Troll', and after it, I received a PM pointing out that someone had been PM'd stating that someone else had gone too far.* I don't remember if it was you who said 'I was a troll', but at the time, actually, I didn't even read it ahahahahah. as I said, get a sense of humour and seriously, the funniest question: please respondS [Gollum] to number 7 Kind Regrds [Edit]names and stones and fixed up tomes, and words that do not break bones[/edit] STAVROS* Last edited by Ivriniel; 12-06-2015 at 06:16 AM.