Game Thread: TIG XCII - Disaster by the Lake

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by G55

#196 - sally reveals.

#209 - she finds her mistake.

Originally Posted by Sally

Yeah. After I'd made the reveal post, I realized I couldn't count correctly.

Yesterday was a really long day. I have no other excuse.

Mmn– except that you list nine villagers at #194, made before your reveal. I can't be the only one to have noticed that.

[Loslote]

Alright, so...Sally's the Hunter. I'll believe her; revealing now seems like the sort of thing she would do. In fact, I think I've seen her do something very similar before as the Hunter (or maybe she was the Ranger and Shasta was the Hunter...it was a very confusing game). I agree that we shouldn't lynch her toDay, but rather than argue about how helpful her reveal was, I'd prefer to accept that she's done it and move on. Look on the positive side: we've narrowed down the list a bit. Our chances of killing us a wolf are a bit better than before.

Speaking of killing us a wolf, I'll be back in about half an hour with time to actually talk about suspiciony things.

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Loslote

Alright, so...Sally's the Hunter. I'll believe her; revealing now seems like the sort of thing she would do. In fact, I think I've seen her do something very similar before as the Hunter (or maybe she was the Ranger and Shasta was the Hunter...it was a very confusing game).

I don't know which game you mean, but yes, she's done this kind of thing before. Only– see my post at #230. Either she's *very* confused, or I've caught her in a lie. I'm not too willing to trust her after that.

[Loslote]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

I don't know which game you mean, but yes, she's done this kind of thing before. Only– see my post at #230. Either she's *very* confused, or I've caught her in a lie. I'm not too willing to trust her after that.

Normally I'd agree with you that that looks fishy, but I don't think that's Sally's style of playing. I'd be surprised if this is all a giant Sally-trick.

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Mmn– except that you list nine villagers at #194, made before your reveal. I can't be the only one to have noticed that.

That post was my reveal, Nerwen.

Originally Posted by me

I think our best option four toDay is, well, the obvious.

Massive reveals, everyone? If so, I'd be happy to start (or rather, finish).

There's no coming back after something that obvious, and it wouldn't have been right to delete or mass-edit my post even if I had realized the full extent of my mistake right off.

I realized my numbers were wrong after I hit submit (which actually means Galadriel's summation is inaccurate, but no matter) and replaced the eight with the nine. Of course then I kept accidentally operating under the assumption that there were eight, which doesn't help with the clarity thing.


Essentially I failed at math. I corrected my number, but kept messing up my math for a few posts until finally I realized, "Oh, nine? That made this whole thing really stupid."


Also, my internet exploded for a bit, so this is x'd since my last post. I'll be back later after I (re)do my analysis of Lottie.

[Loslote]

Sally: I believe her claim to be the Hunter. Not much more to say, is there?
Nog: I've been flip-flopping on him all game. Day 1 he seemed very furry, Day 2 I thought he sounded better, but that "Agan is the cobbler" comment of his yesterDay doesn't sit right with me at all.
Kitanna: She seems reasonable from what I've seen. I haven't played with her much before; I can't really get a grip on her innocence or lack thereof.
Galadriel: She seemed reasonable for a while, but her attitude towards Nog and Sally is a bit worrisome. She seems to decide what she thinks of people and refuses to even look at their posts anymore because she doesn't think her mind can be changed. That seems much more like a wolf, who does know whether or not someone is a wolf and thus doesn't have to wonder whether or not they're wrong than an innocent, who has to keep recalculating and questioning their judgement.
Bom: I can't get a read on him at all.
Shasta: He hasn't posted as much as I would have expected, but I've agreed with most of it, and I can't decide if that makes me nervous about him or more comfortable with him.
Nerwen: Her logic seems sound, but I don't agree with all the conclusions she draws. Really not sure what to make of her.
Greenie: I want to think her innocent, because a lot of what she says seems like it should be innocent, but there's still a nagging feeling in the back of my mind whenever I read her posts...

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Sally

There's no coming back after something that obvious, and it wouldn't have been right to delete or mass-edit my post even if I had realized the full extent of my mistake right off.

Yes, but you hadn't revealed *as* anything... never mind (as Lottie might say ). Either you're a cobbler, probably one who thinks Nog is a wolf– or you're exactly what you say you are, and I'm just too tired now to sort out which.

I'm going to have to vote soon, though, as I can't guarantee being back before DL. I will probably vote for Nog, because of the business yesterDay, though I'd have liked to give him a chance to explain his now-infamous "Agan is the cobbler" statement. Still, after re-reading, he's certainly happy enough for people to, apparently, take it as a Seer-hint...

Other possibilities would be Lottie (Day One stuff), my treasure (role in Agan's lynching) or Kit (Pitch-connection), but those all look like long-shots right now.

[Nerwen]

Oh, and Bom. Maybe he's the cobbler too. Maybe everyone is.

[Nerwen]

Anyway–

++Nogrod

That's the best I can do.

Good luck!