Game Thread: WW LXXXVI - The Halls of Mandos

[Thinlómien]

Commenting while reading...

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Which is another thing– there's been a surprising amount of what looks like signalling. And yet, in this game, why bother?

Well I think it'd always be usufel for the evil side to know each other. After all, if they manage to identify each other, they can join forces. Which makes this:

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Actually– even though there's not much need for a cobbler to hint in this game– that post looks a lot like he's doing just that. "Bingo! Nice work, my wolfish mistress!"

a fair point and makes Boro go quite high on my list of possible cobblers. (Alongside with Phantom, Glirdan, Lottie and several others. I wish I had as many wolf suspects.)

Mmm, people seem to mean that Boro being a cobbler hinting at me means I'm a wolf. Wrong. It only means he thought I'm a wolf, and if you suspect me based on that, you suspect me of being a wolf just because he does. Pretty fishy logic (or high trust in Boro's skills of observance), I'd say.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

So speaking about an "ordo" means an ordinary innocent aka. having no role.
Speaking of an "innocent" means a non-wolf.

NO!!! (Okay I know I'm arguing with a dead person but this is something I feel rather passionately about.) I agree "innocent" doesn't equal "ordo" like some people seem to think, but "innocent" doesn't include cobbler who's not innocent because they're not on the innocent side!!!

Originally Posted by Fea

Edit: crossed with Glirdy... who seems to have spatula'ed himself from one side of the pan to the other. Which, in my brain, sends him from pan to fire... Ie: he didn't really help his cause.

Totally cracked up at this.

Originally Posted by Lottie

TP's being a cobbler makes Lommy look better

Why?

I'm rather worried I have no more to comment. I'm somehow feeling a bit detached from everything, and I think it must have to do with the fact that we don't know the roles of the dead. I think Nogrod was most likelily a cobbler, but if he was the seer that really sucks. However, his role doesn't matter to me that much, I think tp seems rathe cobblerish in any case.

And Fea's death... let's not make the same mistake and leave the evidence of her being picked unanalysed.


xed with all