Tol-in-Gaurhoth LVII - Chess Game for Middle Earth: Game Thread

[Isabellkya]

Originally Posted by Sally

I forgot to add that, conversely, they could choose someone's vote to count twice on a given Day.

If they could choose someone's vote to count twice; then it would've brought the tally to a tie yesterDay. So then, wouldn't Shasta have just said it was a tie, and randomized. Or would he have kept it secret, so as not to reveal too much about the WQ?

- insert an unforeseen short break in here. -

Okay, on to trying to organize some thoughts..

Durelin - no idea

Feanor - she seems her normal self; though what that speaks about the role she holds, I've no idea. Undecided, yet she isn't making me uneasy.

phantom - is phantom. I can never get quite a clear read on him, since he always is his jump-around self. So far, nothing raises giant red flags about him. Though, the trouble with that - is you can never really tell when he is bluffing for real, telling the truth, or bluffing just to bluff. However, I think him innocent.

Brin - no idea

Sally - She worries me. More so, because toDay - I feel she is channeling phantom in her tone. There is nothing wrong with phantom (that I know of), but it is unsettling when he is coming out in another player.

Lariren - Hmm. I find her confusing. Whether it be because she is a confused innocent, or purposely looking confused to hide something; I am not quite sure.

wilwa - she feels innocent to me. Though I would like to see more from her.

Rikae - She seems a bit quiet to me. If I remember previous games correctly, she can be quite a talker.

Eonwe - He is in an unknown category. There isn't much to go off of, and hope he is able to contribute more as he feels better.

Mnemosyne - I'm quite in the middle on her. She makes quite sense-able posts, yet every now and again, something is written that is o.O

Kath - A bit undecided about her. Toward the end of yesterDay I had thought she needed analyzing, because I wasn't so keen on her seeming regurgitation of Nog's reasoning for a vote. I think I will do it anyhow, yet wait to see what she has to say for toDay.

Hansy - While I think him most probable to be an innocent, I am not as comfortable with him toDay; as I was the previous days. Mainly, because he started out quite strong with discussion, yet has kind of pittered since then. I wouldn't vote you toDay, though I would like to see more from you buddy.

....
Looking Innocent:
Phantom, Hansy, Rikae, Wilwa

Undecided:
Eonwe, Kath, Fea, Mnemosyne

Looking notsosparkly:
Sally, Lariren

No idea:
Brin, Durelin

I think I will begin looking at Brin and Durelin; and possibly Mnemosyne and Fea more closely if there is time.. and will wait to possibly look at Kath and Eonwe.

X'd since Sally's #429