Ten Year Anniversary Game: Living Thread

[Macalaure]

Originally Posted by the phantom

I mean really- we're not going to attempt something useful because we're afraid our own side will suck too much to pull it off? No, no, I'm not okay with that.

Day1 is always sketchy in terms of usefulness, but later on? We will do the usual and analyze, as well as we can in this setting, and poke around to see how people are acting. Just because it's not fancy doesn't make it not useful.

Originally Posted by the phantom

If the person doesn't appear as Predator then we trust the reveal, right?

Ah, ok.
I think.
Maybe.
I guess we'll see when we get there.

Originally Posted by Green

so a fake-looking case alone is not as strong a sign of wolfishness as it usually is.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

I'm just a bit confused about the last sentence, the conclusion

Actually, that's a good catch. Wouldn't the conclusion be: "so a good-looking case is not as strong a sign of innocence as it usually is"?

Originally Posted by the phantom

But that was totally different, because the Dead couldn't confirm roles. If they had been able to do so they would've tested Seer-Nog as soon as you went to the Dead thread and suddenly things would've been different.

Maybe it's my memory now, but I think they were. Didn't they just chose not to check Nogrod, because he was so obviously a cobbler.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

and I think the stats might even prove me right in this

A long time ago I actually compiled stats for it. It's somewhere in the grimoire thread. Day1 had the worst odds to catch a wolf. Not saying we shouldn't try, of course.