WW: XCVIII ~ Game Thread ~ Death at the Foot of Taniquetil

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by Pomegranate

Would you mind elaborating that a bit, Nog? I'm not really sure what you're trying to get to.

Not at all, even if I need to try and go to sleep soonish... (happily I don't have work tomorrow at eight)

The first elaboration: it of course means "when we indeed will have more or less none whatever way we play"

But seriously, the idea was this.

You Pom said the following:

Originally Posted by Granate

I personally think that, given how small the amount of villagers there is compared to the amount of wolves, a technique which will keep us from having something to analyse today and tomorrow could prove to be pretty disastrous. The wolves need information, but I think we need information more.

And that of course was a reply to my initial discussion starter as whether we should all act wolvishly to blur the scene from the wolves from finding each other (as they would need to do that).

Now you say there you doubt the merits of the "plan" because it would "keep us from having something to analyse today and tomorrow", and "could prove to be pretty disastrous". Now thinking that the wolves don't know each other, we the villagers already are in that position that we can't deduce or argue about anything from what happened on D1 as there is (probably) no co-operation by the wolves; which is more or less the only thing we might try to catch normally.

So the question becomes, how didn't you realise that? Now if you were a wolf, that would be logical as there would have been no natural way for you to think about that situation from the POV of a villager - which is very different from a normal game indeed this time - but had only thought of it from the POV of a wolf and thus had not noticed it (probably more busy with a thought of how to find your mates which must be a stressing question to a wolf). That would actually be even more believable explanation if you've been busy and had no time to think this properly...


But yeah. That was my D1 reasoning - and I admit it is thin and full of questionmarks / assumptions (which one needs to make if willing to find a wolf). It was the best I could do yesterDay. I hope we'll get more substance in toDay to make more enlightened decisions...