WW LXXXIX: The Terror of Tol Fuin

[Nogrod]

Eomer: so you think Lottiewolf only went agaisnt G55-wolf, not even trying to suspect anyone else the whole Day as to leave her no other option but to vote her mate? And doing that knowingly from the very beginning?

I don't know which of the following is the most odd:
- Lottie doing that?
- You thinking Lottie would do that?
- Me thinking you though Lottie doing that?

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

I don't know which of the following is the most odd:
- Lottie doing that?
- You thinking Lottie would do that?
- Me thinking you though Lottie doing that?

Yes.


It's possible, but I don't find it too terribly likely. At least I don't think so. Oh, heck, I don't know anymore. *runs away sobbing dramatically*

[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

I do think that.

[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

Ok, let me try to clarify why I think Sally is suspicious.

The ordo-reveal which got Kit's back up? Aye, that was suspicious to me. All her other typically crazy posts I always find suspicious; but it's not fair! I'm being Legate to your Eomer ( ) because that's just the way you are.

What really gripped me though was G55's clinging onto you on Day One; and I totally understand that it would be frustrating for you, as an Ordo, to hear me and others keep banging on about it - but I'm sure you understand that it does look off.

Since then you've not really done anything suspicious or innocentish - you've just sort of been there, lurking like all the others. And I'm not certain what your hidden identity is.

I'm finding it very hard in this game to focus on more than 2 or 3 players!

[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

++GALADRIEL55

Obviously.

But I'd be pretty happy if you decided to lynch Sally or Nilp.

The others I can easily picture as innocent. I know some whispers have been made about Lommy but I reckon she's innocent; saw some mumurings about Greenie today too but I'm sure that's nonsense. And that's funny because normally I'd pay for the privilege of voting for either of them!

Legate and Nogrod also seem fair to me, by virtue of their posts.

Mith and Bom - don't know, leaning toward innocent.

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

What really gripped me though was G55's clinging onto you on Day One; and I totally understand that it would be frustrating for you, as an Ordo, to hear me and others keep banging on about it - but I'm sure you understand that it does look off.

Oh, no, I completely understand. You're wrong, mind you, but I can definitely see it. I don't mind that you're suspecting me, because you have a fairly logical case, even though I'm not actually guilty. Suspect away! Just vote for someone else.


EDIT: x'd since the post I quoted, and you did. Heh. Shiny.

[Nogrod]

I see both Greenie and Sally have questioned my voting. so as I need to go to sleep a bit earlier I might try to elucidate them so as not to leave mis-interpreted talking-points on the surface.

I realised more or less immediately after submitting my vote on D1 that the choice of words "I see this has been decided" wasn't exactly the best one. But it was in a way conveying my stance there anyway. I had been suspecting Sally for some time for her quick defending herself while I hadn't even suspected her yet (etc. check the thread for details) but as the DL draw closer I got more and more involved with Lottie finding her increasingly suspicious.

But both "cases" were quite weak - as they tend to be on D1 - and thus I could have voted either of them. Seeing Lommy & Legate both voting Lottie I then thought it was going to be Lottie who faced the gallows and thought that it was okay by me as I did suspect her (and their votes saved me from choosing between the two as I didn't have a major case against Sally to argue that it should be definitively her and not Lottie).


On my vote on D2 I can only say that it was a gut reaction of someone realising he should have to go to bed like now and not in half an hour. Yes I had found Kitanna suspicious the whole Day - and I was wholly prepared to vote for her. And even now, knowing she was innocent I stand behind my suspicions from there: she looked suspicious for both what she did herself and what Lottie's posts implied. We now know those were wrong, but we (I) didn't yesterDay.

But the sudden bandwagon over her just felt soo wrong. It felt like something very sinister with the "easy votes" coming in and I had to just quit in a minute or two. So I made an impulsive decision to try and give you another candidate to vote (I had explained why I thought Mith to be suspicious) to end what looked like a beginning of a really easy bandwagon if Kit was after all innocent (which I doubted but still feared was possible). And you all know the result of that vote...

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

I do think that.

I'm still waiting for the "like"-button like Facebook has for these smaller appreciations...


Okay. Time to think of voting now.


EDIT: X'd with Eomer X a few