Mandos Thread: DEAD ONLY! - WW LXXXVI

[Thinlómien]

Originally Posted by Agan

If you are only throwing an idea out there without actually suggesting it, you usually don't portray it in a nearly flawless light when there are both pros and cons to it.

I didn't portray it in a nearly flawless light and besides, the flaws should be obvious and they've been mentioned on this thread several times.

Originally Posted by Agan

I pointed out a flaw in your logic but it wasn't a personal attack.

No you didn't. It's a completely different thing to say "hey mate, there's a flaw in your logic" than "faulty logic! I smells evil!" and they provoke completely different reactions in the people whose logic you criticise. You can try experimenting with that.

And even though I know there'll be more jungle knives and pole axes for this, I really still don't see what's so utterly bad about my plan. Yes, it has vices. But so does the current plan. But it's not like I can take my plan through alone or that you need my cooperation for anything, so no need to get aggressive about it.


On a totally different issue, we're going to have rather tricky time toMorrow (assuming we stick with the original plan) because we still don't know which mode of communication the village is expecting of us, but we still have plenty time to think about that.

And then I should still vote toDay. I'd still see Nessa's role revealed as being far more useful than mine being revealed, but if you insist on sticking to the original plan, I guess there's not much I can do. Of course I've never gone Nilp before, which might be an interesting experience.

Being dead is more frustrating than I ever expected it to be and we're all stuck here until the end of the game... envy those blasted mortals.