Mandos Thread: DEAD ONLY! - WW LXXXVI

[Nogrod]

Shasta, I'm really sorry about my language 12 hours ago, but I was soo freaking frustrated back then on why you didn't get what I was trying to say and which seemed so obvious to me...

But now I think I understand better and see I had ignored at least one major issue back there. And that actually changes things - making also your reluctance to believe me quite more understandable.

For I had somehow managed to ignore Agan's bluff where she said she was Lúthien... I should have noted it and refuted it.

The fun part of this is that I actually remember seeing that "revelation" but I just skimmed it as her saying she was a lover, not realising she said it the wrong way.

But then again, and to my believabilty, I did say she is Beren from the get-go quite openly and never claimed she was Lúthien. Because she isn't. She is Beren.


So, I do apologise again from you, and hope you will see why I reacted that way: having not reacted to that bluff by Agan, which you understandably interpreted as me bluffing, I was totally puzzled and frustrated why you didn't see my point...