WWLXII: Dead Men Do Tell Tales

[Eönwë]

Originally Posted by Macalaure

In that case, the real seer must either have made a ridiculous blunder, or is still alive, which would mean that Izzy is the real seer, even though she claims it's not so.

It could be Gwath, but whatever the case, the real seer, if they are still alive, they should not reveal, as it seems like there's a cobbler alive too. But then again, why would they leave it so late when there's a chance that they could get killed.
Because of this I think that if Greenie wasn't really the seer, it would have to have been either one of the modfired ones or Gwath. However, we'll never know, so it's probably best if we try to take Greenie's message on board, as that's the only possible information we really have on the living.