WWLXII: Dead Men Do Tell Tales

[Boromir88]

Question: Was Gwath "gone" when there was a no-kill?~Shasta

Yes, but I'm fairly sure Izzy missed a day pretty early in the going too, so that might be really hard to tell anything from it. Now you know why I get frustrated over multiple people missing at the same time.

Though, I still think the key is why Nerwen wasn't killed, and why you...would Izzy have gotten rid of someone who would likely vote against her, to keep you and Gwath, but also make her look more guilty by killing Nerwen? Or is Gwath hoping to use Nerwen's strong suspicion against Izzy, to vote for her, and put this game away?

I think looking at either Mac's interactions between Gwath and Izzy, or Lommy's interactions between the two, are just red herrings at this point. I mean in this situation who's to say how mutineers would act amongst themselves? And it all depends upon personal bias...whether you think Mac is a wolf, or Lommy. There's no doubt one is, I obviously believe it's Mac, Mac obviously believes it's Lommy...but that will just confuse the situation. The key is who would benefit more from an innocent Nerwen still being alive at this point, and not an innocent Shasta? Izzy or Gwath?