WWLXII: Dead Men Do Tell Tales

[Isabellkya]

Nice of you to finally hop on the "Izzy is a Cobbler" Train Shasta.

Nice of you as well Eonwe. Both of you need to pay double for jumping on so late. Plus double that for being wrong.

No, Nerwen. Perhaps you need to go and re-read my posts.
I haven't hinted at anything.
This has been covered already.

Haha. Had to pre-emptive it eh?

Which is it Nerwen? Wolf or Cobbler. I can't be both. Unluckily for you, I am neither.

Boro - Nerwen will probably still try to "look innocent", even though she isn't.

Interesting that you "suddenly" step up your post count and involvement Nerwen.

What exactly is "the profile" of a Cobbler, Shasta? And how do I "fit it better"?

Izzy is not a Cobbler.

[Isabellkya]

ToDay, my vote will be for Nerwen or Shasta. I think.

Though Eonwe already voting for Shasta makes me pause.

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Isabellkya

Haha. Had to pre-emptive it eh?

Oh, you were going to play Seer? Ha ha yourself.

Originally Posted by Isabellkya

Which is it Nerwen? Wolf or Cobbler. I can't be both. Unluckily for you, I am neither.

If you're neither I should rather say, "unluckily for the village". People say you're a Cobbler because you're acting like one. They also say you might be a wolf... because that's pretty much the only other thing you could be.

Once again: it makes no sense whatever to think I'm a mutineer at this stage. Yet you're still talking of voting me!

Not the action of an innocent, Izzy.

[Nerwen]

I don't know. I suppose it's out of Eönwë and Shasta now.

So–

++ Eönwë

Of the two, he's looked worse toDay.

[Isabellkya]

And yes, this is one situation in which I feel entirely justified in suspecting anyone who suspects me of being a wolf. - Nerwen

Haha. Had to pre-emptive it eh? - Izzy

"Not the action of an innocent, Izzy."

I think I've said the same of you Nerwen.
I've even elaborated on why I don't think you've been acting like an innocent.
Yet I think it took another person, or persons of calling me a Cobbler- before you hopped on the wagon.


Yes. Wolf or Cobbler.
It really does depend on what post is being read of yours.

How am I acting like a Cobbler?

[Isabellkya]

How is it out of Eonwe and Shasta?

Only one person had made their vote.

[Shastanis Althreduin]

++Eonwe

For reasons previously stated.

[Isabellkya]

Feel free to answer the questions before deadline Shasta.

[Shastanis Althreduin]

If you're talking about the "profile of a Cobbler" question, Izzy, it's because you've repeatedly ignored Greenie's Seer claim and tried to paint Nerwen as a mutineer, without giving a single good reason why Greenie's claim is false.

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Isabellkya

"Not the action of an innocent, Izzy."

I think I've said the same of you Nerwen.
I've even elaborated on why I don't think you've been acting like an innocent.
Yet I think it took another person, or persons of calling me a Cobbler- before you hopped on the wagon

I've been saying you were evil for Days. I don't know if I was the first (I think that was Rikae) but I don't see that as relevant. Nobody could act as you have and fail to be suspected. How could you expect otherwise?

Originally Posted by Isabellkya

Yes. Wolf or Cobbler.
It really does depend on what post is being read of yours. ;

No. Mostly I think you're a cobbler, but now and then I have a nasty moment of doubt where I think, "Surely a real cobbler wouldn't be so blatant?"

Originally Posted by Isabellkya

How am I acting like a Cobbler?

I've already given the number one reason. More than once, I believe. It doesn't matter whether you think I'm "acting like an innocent". You cannot logically think it likely I'm a mutineer, and that's what matters now.

EDIT: X'd with Shasta and Izzy (2 of each).