WWLXII: Dead Men Do Tell Tales

[Gwathagor]

*just notices sally's second to last post*

Hey, WHAAAT?

Now there's a cobbler if I've ever seen one. Probably trying to draw attention away from Mac.

[Gwathagor]

Out of curiosity - has anyone considered trying to lynch a ghost? I've been gone for the past couple of days, so I don't really know what's happened, but maybe there's a ghost whose total demise could give us some very helpful certainty. Otherwise it's just going to be total guesswork right until the end and as right as we think we might be about someone's guilt or innocence, we'll never know for sure. Am I the only one who thinks that this might be a good idea?

[Shastanis Althreduin]

No, you're not, Gwath, but I'm thinking it might be a better idea to resolve the Mac situation first.

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Gwathagor

Out of curiosity - has anyone considered trying to lynch a ghost? I've been gone for the past couple of days, so I don't really know what's happened, but maybe there's a ghost whose total demise could give us some very helpful certainty. Otherwise it's just going to be total guesswork right until the end and as right as we think we might be about someone's guilt or innocence, we'll never know for sure. Am I the only one who thinks that this might be a good idea?

If there's three wolves left, that's suicidal.

Besides, Sally's confessed to being a baddy. She might not be a wolf, though... but then again she might. I'm sure she's trying to get us to double-kill her, either way.

[Nerwen]

If we survive toDay, we'll know at least two wolves are down.

[Gwathagor]

What about these ghosts, anyway? I want to take a closer look at the ones that have continued to be involved after their deaths, since I that takes a lot of dedication and almost certainly in some of the cases indicates some kind of ulterior motive. But which ones - ?

Anyway, I actually have to go watch Foyle's War now. I am willing to agree to Mac's lynch, but I would be very interesting in enacting a second lynch one one of our ghosts toMorrow.

Ah, feeling scattered, sorry - have to run.

++Mac

[Inziladun]

Originally Posted by Gwathagor

What about these ghosts, anyway? I want to take a closer look at the ones that have continued to be involved after their deaths, since I that takes a lot of dedication and almost certainly in some of the cases indicates some kind of ulterior motive. But which ones - ?

I believe Boro, Nogrod and I were all night-killed, so I think it would mostly be a waste. Nogrod is, I think, the only active ghost there could legitimately be some doubt about. And Lommy, I suppose. I realize I'm just a powerless voice in the darkness here, but I don't think you can afford to chase the ghosts this close to the end.
As to why I'm still here, I'm interested in this game and I want to see it to the end, that's all. It's the weekend, too. So unless I come down with the nasty virus that's been plaguing my daughter, I plan to be around the next day as well.

[Macalaure]

Gah, almost everytime I get lynched it's because RL gets in the way and I can't be there to defend myself.

I guess now it's decided. At least I will still be able to contribute as a ghost, and maybe some will even listen to me.

[Isabellkya]

Vote time.

++Nerwen

[Macalaure]

Too tired right now to properly refute anything.

Boro, what you say about my Kath-vote makes no sense. It seriously doesn't.

If I really was a wolf, I'd gladly accept your props, Boro.

I think the bottom line is what Gwath said - what I did would have as much holes if I was a wolf than in reality. You're biased, Boro, because you can't get the idea out of your head that Lommy is innocent. But I understand that, it's the default reaction for any werewolf player to lynch somebody who presents them a story like mine. Just look what everyone else did (except Izzy, but she's.... let's say unique). You merely backed it up with theory.

I have to give props in turn to Nog, Inzy, and Gwath for considering what I said could be true. Actually, I'm considering to remove Gwath from my high suspicion. He's been pretty sensible since he came back. (Then again, he kept on harping on the double kill, which is indeed a bad idea at this point.) Of course, with my recent doubt of Eonwe, this leaves me with 0 wolves. I haven't checked the actual numbers, but I'm sure we have at least one more day. I'll make up my mind about the baddies again and try to help you with whatever I will come up with.

Originally Posted by Inziladun

I believe Boro, Nogrod and I were all night-killed, so I think it would mostly be a waste.

Nogrod was picked by the hunter.

[Nerwen]

Izzy, sweetheart, have some common sense.

It's perfectly reasonable for me to think you're a baddie when you've been fixated on me ever since Greenie named me innocent. (There are other things, e.g. your behaviour to Rikae after her Hunter-reveal.)

Wolves are less likely to go all out after a semi-known innocent, because it brings them out into the open, and because they can kill at Night anyway. Besides, for a cobbler who doesn't have a good idea of who the wolves are, someone like me is the only safe vote.

Ergo, you're probably a cobbler. However, I could be wrong: you might be a mutineer trying to look like one... I've played that game myself.

Now quiet. We're lynching Mac toDay. I really don't think you're going to swing it my way.

EDIT: X'd with Mac.

[Nerwen]

++Macalaure

For reasons stated previously.

X'd with Gwath and Shasta.

[Isabellkya]

Nog, Nerwen and I were the only ones to change our votes from Mac to Lommy.

No Zil, that was not in response to that quote. It was in response to something else that she said.

Nice try though.


No, I don't believe Greenie's claim and the subsequent assumed innocence of Nerwen.

Greenie would do something like that. Along with Nerwen's following behavior, I really doubt she is the seer.

As I stated previously - Nerwen isn't acting like an innocent, nor anywhere near someone whom is in the realm of a known innocent. She isn't being thoughtful with her votes and her reasonings.

She seems to have only named me a Cobbler or a Mutie - because I called her out first. Defensive reaction in that manner - is suspicious. Suspecting someone only because they suspect you first? Uhh yeah.


X'd with Nerwen x2, and Gwath.