WWLXII: Dead Men Do Tell Tales

[Macalaure]

Originally Posted by Lommy

I agree Eönwë hasn't helped us too much - except with his handy tables and a point or two - but it doesn't surely mean he's a mutineer. I can imagine him being just intimidated by the setting and not pushing his way to make points against other people, like you and me have done, but that doesn't give any clue to his role.

If this isn't a mutineer defending a mutineer then I don't know what is. Handy tables usually fall into the category of "looking helpful without being helpful" because they don't give you genuine thought - you know that very well. On the next one I call you: Which were the one or two points you found helpful. List. Also, I did not say "He isn't helpful, he's evil", but "He posted a lot of evil things, and he isn't even helpful, he's evil". Nobody has to push points against others, but stating opinions isn't asked too much.

Originally Posted by Lommy

Nay, Mac, I've made that mistake once and I wouldn't do it again. I've lost one game because of being so certain and desperate on the last Day, so if I was a wolf now, I'd be really much more careful and subtle and not attack you like a rabid dog.

In a regular game I would maybe even believe that, but in this setup with barely any knowledge? Nope. Look how many think you're innocent just because you're so bold. It's a risky move, and you are pulling it well - but you have not won yet