The Narn i Chîn Húrin: Beleg & Falivirn - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Findegil · 05-20-2009, 12:45 AM

Since you ask for a third person to interfer, here are my two pence:

NA-RG-21: I would go with Aiwendils line. for one it is the smaller change and it avoids the 'Guilinion' which is surely valid, but which we never used before.

NA-RG-17: Conservativisem rules for me here so it is Aiwendils line.

NA-SL-04: I looked into it as well when you brought up the problem. Aiwendil is surely right that we can not say that the molestade poeple were Noldor. The candidates are Poeple of Haleth folk from Brethil, Woodmen south of Taeglin and remanants of Marachs folk from south of Ered Wethrin plus probably a view wandering Sindarin-Elves and fare reaching Scouts of Nargothrond. I have no solution at hand. The line is not easily removed either since it is needed for the whole part about the Orks ransacking.

NA-RG-57: Even so Gwindor is discribed very good by being 'faithfull', I think he can be called a friend by the virture of guardinf Túrin up to tht point.

Respectfully
Findegil

05-20-2009, 12:45 AM	#31
Findegil King's Writer Join Date: Jul 2002 Posts: 1,721	Since you ask for a third person to interfer, here are my two pence: NA-RG-21: I would go with Aiwendils line. for one it is the smaller change and it avoids the 'Guilinion' which is surely valid, but which we never used before. NA-RG-17: Conservativisem rules for me here so it is Aiwendils line. NA-SL-04: I looked into it as well when you brought up the problem. Aiwendil is surely right that we can not say that the molestade poeple were Noldor. The candidates are Poeple of Haleth folk from Brethil, Woodmen south of Taeglin and remanants of Marachs folk from south of Ered Wethrin plus probably a view wandering Sindarin-Elves and fare reaching Scouts of Nargothrond. I have no solution at hand. The line is not easily removed either since it is needed for the whole part about the Orks ransacking. NA-RG-57: Even so Gwindor is discribed very good by being 'faithfull', I think he can be called a friend by the virture of guardinf Túrin up to tht point. Respectfully Findegil