Tol-in-Gaurhoth XLVII: Dueling Wizards Werewolf II - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

satansaloser2005 · 06-06-2008, 09:17 PM

DI
#241 (6:33pm)
Jokes of family conspiracy. Asks Phantom about his no-vote. Comments about Day One arguments (agrees with Cailin, then says Cailin is evil because Nerwen was innocent.) Jokes about family ties again. Says if she was EW she would do a lot of the same things the EW is doing. Boasts she's only been lynched once.

Only lynched one, eh? Is this a challenge, dear cousin? However, I don't think she'd be this straightforward if she was the EW, even if she couldn't be lynched. Still, this sits wrong with me. And Cailin is evil because Nerwen isn't? Come up with something better please sweetie. I know you can....Cailin bothers me too for various reasons. I'll get to them, but not now....moving on....

#242 (6:38pm)
Urges others to post. Nothing of consequence.

#257 (10:05pm)
Teases Phantom about his no-vote again. Hypothesizes that Volo's death had something to do with his seership and Agan's role. Goes nuts and goes into bloody descriptions about killing Agan.

SADIST! Kudos on being right though, even if you were just kidding.

#268 (10:54pm)
Joking continuation of the seer dream discussion. Silly and fun, insightful and yet nothing.

#290 (12:05am)
Joking. Teases Phantom for being....well, for being Phantom.

#312 (12:40am)
Mentions Roa's behavior in a previous game and compares it to Phantom's current actions.

#404 (2:59pm)
Complains about the high post velocity. Says the Roa and Phantom argument is entertaining; wants to know their roles.

Told ya so. You can't have your posts and read them too, people. And I'd like to know what they are, but for now let's leave them alone and try to figure it out without, I dunno, KILLING them, okay? Goodie.

#410 (3:13pm)
Erm, yeah. Random stuff.

#414 (3:29pm)
Wonders about a previous Cailin post (now cleared up). Says she won't mind being lynched, but tells Cailin that lynching her right after Nerwen is a poor choice. Also says she's not all that innocent.

Hmmmm. Mehbe she's an ex-wolf? A stretch, I know, but that last “I'm not all that innocent” bit makes me think she's been scried, either into a fur coat or out of it. Or maybe she's just being silly.

#424 (3:50pm)
Says useful posts are no fun. Wants to argue/read arguments (like Roa and Phantom) and jokes that she'll make stuff up if it gets discussion going.

She's got to be kidding! Fortunately, I think she is. I hope....

#426 (3:58pm)
Says she'll keep a close eye on Shasta, as she finds him sneaky.

My grandpa is a nice man. Maybe he just needs a shave. *shifty eyes*

#443 (4:51pm)
Suspicion list. Suspicious: Shasta, Lommie, Kath, Mac, Rikae, Cailin, Lallie, Cabbie. Wants more from Cellie, Morm, Gwath, and others. Notes that people will change sides frequently and suggests we should look for wizards, as they're the only consistent players. Speaks up about wizard suspects (mostly Phantom and Rikae).

Heh, she says Phantom bribed Noggie with Husker crap to gain wizardship (that would be a DETERRENT, love....). I like her take on wizards. Since they don't change, they are the only people that are guaranteed to leave some sort of trail (not a trail I guess more than evidence after they're dead, i.e. Who they picked, why, etc.) and so maybe we should concentrate on the wizard (EW, at least) more heavily than we have been. Bah, this has been discussed to death. Moving on.

#450 (5:04pm)
Still likes reading arguments. Is happy to see Cellie talking, and especially that Cellie also finds Cailin wolfish.

Happy to see someone else on her side. Can't argue with that.

#458 (5:14pm)
Joking. Suspects Lommie.

#461 (5:18pm)
Joking with Durie.

#490 (5:41pm)
Confused about who to vote for. Silly.

#500 (5:47pm)
Votes for Mac. Jokes about getting spanked for voting her dad, but otherwise no commentary.

Six minutes between “no idea who to vote for” and “let's kill Mac”. Then again, I've done it before too, so I can't say a whole lot about it. Slightly worrisome, but she mentioned suspicion of him earlier so it didn't completely come out of nowhere.

#538 (6:00pm)
Comments again on post volume. Pulls a “whoops” about voting Mac.

Erm....oopsie? Again, happens to the best of us. I hope you got a good whipping though.

Okay, so Di rubs me a bit the wrong way. Nothing screaming "lynch me, lynch me" but quite a few little things that make me hesitate to call her innocent. Definitely in the yellow area, bordering on orange. It's easy to hide fur behind fun.

Okay. A few points before I submit. One. I'm too lazy to bold (though I'll probably do it in a bit anyway). Two. I write too big; Di alone took up over three pages in my notebook, and that's just for day two! Three. I only had day two pages saved, so that's what I worked with. Sorry. Four. I'm flipping posting this.

Diamond18 · 06-06-2008, 09:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

Erm....oopsie? Again, happens to the best of us. I hope you got a good whipping though.

Well since dear Daddy is dead (RIP) his ghost will have to rise up from the grave to do so. Actually I got a PM from him saying "Dear Diamond, I know your real name, I can find out where you live. I AM COMING FOR YOU."

(Not really.)

I enjoyed your analysis of me very much, btw. I have no complaints.

satansaloser2005 · 06-06-2008, 09:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Diamond18

Well since dear Daddy is dead (RIP) his ghost will have to rise up from the grave to do so. Actually I got a PM from him saying "Dear Diamond, I know your real name, I can find out where you live. I AM COMING FOR YOU."

(Not really.)

I enjoyed your analysis of me very much, btw. I have no complaints.

Haha. I'd totally do that, you know.

Okay, battery's dying. May be back tonight, may not. Depends. See you upon my return. And as always, post IN MODERATION

while I'm gone.

Rikae · 06-06-2008, 09:51 PM

Well, as far as I can see, there's only one reasonable conclusion to come to - Legate is a wolf. Sally's theory points to it, Diamond's theory points to it, and, hey, my theory points to it, too. Q.E.D.

There is one other thing becoming apparent - people who do analyses really need to put more of their own opinions into them (not just a one liner at the end) and distinguish between summary and commentary somehow. Otherwise, it's just annoying to read.

Shastanis Althreduin · 06-06-2008, 09:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rikae

There is one other thing becoming apparent - people who do analyses really need to put more of their own opinions into them (not just a one liner at the end) and distinguish between summary and commentary somehow. Otherwise, it's just annoying to read.

Okay, noted.

Rikae · 06-06-2008, 09:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shasta

Okay, noted.

The Legate part too, I hope.

Shastanis Althreduin · 06-06-2008, 09:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rikae

The Legate part too, I hope.

And haven't I been saying I think Legate's probably furry?

Shastanis Althreduin · 06-06-2008, 09:33 PM

Gwath, Day 1

#48 - First post. Amused at Roa and Phantom squabbling. Believes that the key to the game is tracking down the EW.

#73 - Believes Aganzir to be twisting his words. Votes for Sally without an explanation.

Gwath, Day 2

#277 - Quotes a post of Sally; partially explains his vote for her by saying she seemed too "sane". Thinks Eonwe's vote for Phantom is suspicious. Thinks Roa is suspicious for voting Phantom as well. Thinks Phantom is also suspicious for dominating the conversation. Wary of Diamond's reason for voting Nerwen, as well as her apparent neutrality. Raises an eyebrow at the number of random votes cast. Suspicious of Lalaith, based on her posting style.

#286 - Sort of, kind of, explains his vote for Sally.

#310 - Replies to Ka. Admits he's been quieter than usual. Won't be around for the deadline again, so must vote early.

#361 - Certain that either Roa or Phantom is a wolf, based on their argument.

#362 - Explains his vote for Sally a bit more, based on her posting style, but mentions that he believes her to be "back to normal".

#365 - Would like to vote Phantom or Roa, but doesn't. Gives Eonwe an extra day for being new. Thinks Sally to be acting more innocently. Votes Lalaith for much the same reason he voted Sally.

Gwath - Day 3

#562 - States intention to be more involved. Thinks Rikae quick to jump on Legate; sides with Legate.

#577 - Wants to see more of the feud between Roa and Phantom. Thinks it's possible that Phantom is being a bit arrogant.

#579 - Gives up his idea on Phantom quickly, once Rikae voices her displeasure. This makes me raise an eyebrow.

#581 - Suddenly wonders why Rikae is so eager to deflect attention from Roa and Phantom. The eyebrow goes back down, but not all the way.

#591 - Reiterates that the wolves probably don't know each other.

To sum up:

Gwath bothers me a bit, but not to the extent that Legate does. I'd put him as a 4 on the scale; leaning innocent.

06-06-2008, 09:33 PM	#8
Shastanis Althreduin Werewolf Psychic Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: In fire, water, earth, and air. But mostly water. Posts: 2,832	Gwath, Day 1 #48 - First post. Amused at Roa and Phantom squabbling. Believes that the key to the game is tracking down the EW. #73 - Believes Aganzir to be twisting his words. Votes for Sally without an explanation. Gwath, Day 2 #277 - Quotes a post of Sally; partially explains his vote for her by saying she seemed too "sane". Thinks Eonwe's vote for Phantom is suspicious. Thinks Roa is suspicious for voting Phantom as well. Thinks Phantom is also suspicious for dominating the conversation. Wary of Diamond's reason for voting Nerwen, as well as her apparent neutrality. Raises an eyebrow at the number of random votes cast. Suspicious of Lalaith, based on her posting style. #286 - Sort of, kind of, explains his vote for Sally. #310 - Replies to Ka. Admits he's been quieter than usual. Won't be around for the deadline again, so must vote early. #361 - Certain that either Roa or Phantom is a wolf, based on their argument. #362 - Explains his vote for Sally a bit more, based on her posting style, but mentions that he believes her to be "back to normal". #365 - Would like to vote Phantom or Roa, but doesn't. Gives Eonwe an extra day for being new. Thinks Sally to be acting more innocently. Votes Lalaith for much the same reason he voted Sally. Gwath - Day 3 #562 - States intention to be more involved. Thinks Rikae quick to jump on Legate; sides with Legate. #577 - Wants to see more of the feud between Roa and Phantom. Thinks it's possible that Phantom is being a bit arrogant. #579 - Gives up his idea on Phantom quickly, once Rikae voices her displeasure. This makes me raise an eyebrow. #581 - Suddenly wonders why Rikae is so eager to deflect attention from Roa and Phantom. The eyebrow goes back down, but not all the way. #591 - Reiterates that the wolves probably don't know each other. To sum up: Gwath bothers me a bit, but not to the extent that Legate does. I'd put him as a 4 on the scale; leaning innocent. __________________ Shasta– ... However, if he's innocent his famous clairvoyant powers must be taking the week off. Meanwhile, the Night-kills have been awfully effective– almost like we're dealing with a psychic wolf... - Nerwen, WW LXXV Last edited by Shastanis Althreduin; 06-06-2008 at 09:34 PM. Reason: X'd with Lhuna, Sally, Sally, Diamond.

06-06-2008, 09:51 PM	#4
Rikae Mellifluous Maia Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: A glade open to the stars, deep in Nan Elmoth Posts: 3,489	Well, as far as I can see, there's only one reasonable conclusion to come to - Legate is a wolf. Sally's theory points to it, Diamond's theory points to it, and, hey, my theory points to it, too. Q.E.D. There is one other thing becoming apparent - people who do analyses really need to put more of their own opinions into them (not just a one liner at the end) and distinguish between summary and commentary somehow. Otherwise, it's just annoying to read.