New evidence for the Arkenstone-Silmaril case

[Landroval]

Thanks for the welcome.

Originally Posted by Nerwen

None– but some of us might just get a bit irritated at being characterised as "those with closed minds", mightn't we?

Yes, poor choice of phrasing on my part, and bad foot to get off on in a first post. I suppose that's what happens when one is posting when one should be sleeping. I'll edit in the hope of avoiding further offense. Please accept my apologies, in any case.



I don't believe I was trying to have my cake and eat it to, was merely postulating, for the sake of argument, that if the Arkenstone was a Silmaril, it might have then directly led to Smaug's downfall by providing a weakness in his defenses.

The One Ring also could not be unmade "by any craft we here possess," yet could be destroyed in the fires from which it was made. That being the case, I don't see why Trumpkin Mahalel's point that time in the fires of the world's mantel would not be allow a Silmaril to be marred during the period where it was cooling down once more.