Tol-in-Gaurhoth (Isle of Werewolves)

[Galadriel55]

Originally Posted by Kuru

Basically we need to ask ourselves, what would*the phantom*do to break the game to turn it in his favor depending on what side he was on.

It would definitely involve a disregard for the intended twist of the game, a very convincing false reveal, and annoying the pants off of half the village.

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Kuru

Basically we need to ask ourselves, what would*the phantom*do to break the game to turn it in his favor depending on what side he was on.

This should be framed and hung on the wall of every mod planning an experimental game.

[Nerwen]

Another clarification request- how does the Visitor enter the Dead Thread in the first place? Only by being lynched or killed? Or is there a voluntary option?

[Nerwen]

Do we feel like making another attempt at recruiting those highbrow types from their ivory tower in the Books forum?

[Kuruharan]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Another clarification request- how does the Visitor enter the Dead Thread in the first place? Only by being lynched or killed? Or is there a voluntary option?

Ahh...you noticed my ambiguity on that point.

I haven't completely decided.

I am, however, open to opinions.

It does seem a little odd to my mind to pick a Visitor and then try to kill them, but at the same time in the other Dead Thread games the special people in question also had to be killed. The difference this time is the Good Wizard would be deliberately picking a Visitor.

This also brings up the question of do I tell the Visitor that they have been picked as such. We must bring Nilp out of retirement. This could be a role where he could really shine.

Of course for him at this point it is a little bit of been there done that.

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Kuruharan

Ahh...you noticed my ambiguity on that point.

I haven't completely decided.

I am, however, open to opinions.

It does seem a little odd to my mind to pick a Visitor and then try to kill them, but at the same time in the other Dead Thread games the special people in question also had to be killed. The difference this time is the Good Wizard would be deliberately picking a Visitor.

This also brings up the question of do I tell the Visitor that they have been picked as such. We must bring Nilp out of retirement. This could be a role where he could really shine.

Of course for him at this point it is a little bit of been there done that.

This actually made me laugh out loud for ages, like a lunatic.. Lucky there's no-one else home.

[Kuruharan]

Perhaps a compromise...one Visitor goes into the Dead Thread at the start of the next DAY and the other Visitor has to be killed?

That might spice up the tactical options a bit.

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Kuruharan

Perhaps a compromise...one Visitor goes into the Dead Thread at the start of the next DAY and the other Visitor has to be killed?

That might spice up the tactical options a bit.

For some reason (idiocy, probably) I read this as a sort of conditional statement- "If Visitor #1 goes into the Dead Thread then Visitor #2 has to be killed [the Day after]", but you just mean their roles work differently, right?