Tol-in-Guarhoth CIX - Ten Year Anniversary Game: Dead Thread

[the phantom]

Originally Posted by Morm

morm is a wolf give vote to Form or McCaber
Form is a wolf give vote to morm or Lommy
Kath is a wolf give vote to Eomer or Mith
Mith is a wolf give vote to Kath or Shasta
McCaber is a wolf give vote to Boro
No dreams on this list as wolf give vote to Sally

Ha ha, I love it, especially that he's a Wolf suggesting this. Way to go Mith for forcing the conversation toward the Living!

Originally Posted by Mith

We know that there must be a majority of innocents in the dead thread now and that they seem to be horrifically active. I know given my vehement opposition to rigged voting day one but if we arranged a tie either of the unknowns or even go the whole hog and all just self vote then the dead can either take out a known wolf or if they don't know any leave us all to bicker another day. Too much of a risk of something going wrong?

Yes!!!! This is EXACTLY the sort of thing I had in mind. Mith- you have become Phantom!

Anyway, it's quite easy to get caught up on the Living thread, but the Dead thread is another matter.

*goes to read*

[the phantom]

I'm trying to get caught up but I can't move beyond Agan's post where Bilbo becomes Cage. I'm just watching it over and over.

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Originally Posted by the phantom

Yes!!!! This is EXACTLY the sort of thing I had in mind. Mith- you have become Phantom!

Make sure she hears that. Interesting, given that she was most anti-Phantom on first Day. You should thank her!

Anyway, as for myself and DL, I won't really be here for the DL (no way), but I will try to vote when there is at least something to start with. For instance, when someone votes for one of our Wolves, or somesuch. Or, of course, if someone votes for a Wolf and in such a way that we can send a message that way as well. Of course, I don't want to be too greedy.

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Legate of Amon Lanc

Make sure she hears that. Interesting, given that she was most anti-Phantom on first Day. You should thank her!

Anyway, as for myself and DL, I won't really be here for the DL (no way), but I will try to vote when there is at least something to start with. For instance, when someone votes for one of our Wolves, or somesuch. Or, of course, if someone votes for a Wolf and in such a way that we can send a message that way as well. Of course, I don't want to be too greedy.

I'll try to do the same.

[the phantom]

This might be one of those once-in-a-decade Werewolf games where you need to set an alarm.

[Aganzir]

Originally Posted by the phantom

This might be one of those once-in-a-decade Werewolf games where you need to set an alarm.

Which is what I'm thinking of doing. No promises though, and if it can be avoided I'd rather.

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by the phantom

This might be one of those once-in-a-decade Werewolf games where you need to set an alarm.

It's not early for me- it just happens to fall at a time when I may not be able to get online.

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by Legate of Amon Lanc

Anyway, as for myself and DL, I won't really be here for the DL (no way), but I will try to vote when there is at least something to start with. For instance, when someone votes for one of our Wolves, or somesuch. Or, of course, if someone votes for a Wolf and in such a way that we can send a message that way as well. Of course, I don't want to be too greedy.

Fits me as well.

Lot to do tomorrow so no staying awake up to 5am. Sorry.

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by Shasta

I half wonder if we shouldn't ask the dead thread a simple question, like how many wolves are in the dead thread right now? Like -

If it's 1, give Lommy the extra vote
If it's 2, give Shasta the extra vote
If it's 3, give Eomer the extra vote
If it's 4, give Mith the extra vote
If it's 5, give Boro the extra vote
If it's 6, give McCaber the extra vote

- or something like that. Thoughts?

No Mr. Ranger, no...

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by Boro

Morm's pairs would work the best if Nerwen got a wolf in one of her final dreams.

Lommy's if she got innocents. But it leaves the door open for a bad lynch since the innocents aren't infallible.

Mith's suggestion of everyone self-voting and letting the dead decide if they know a living wolf would be great, if everyone goes through with it. But it leaves the door open for wolf funny business, which would out their wolvery. Although I would just kill them in the night then, that might be enough of a deterrence?

It's really up to the collective of the village. I have no problem self-voting.

I'm always for stepping back and taking a good look at things and different options one has... but if they are now going to open a discussion on all options there will be nothing sorted out before three hours from now - or something.

How many "secure" voters do we have there at the DL against wolves aka. is there a good argument for early-sleepers not to vote at all if there seems to be happening nothing in the Living thread in say 1-1½ hours the most?

[Rikae]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

How many "secure" voters do we have there at the DL against wolves aka. is there a good argument for early-sleepers not to vote at all if there seems to be happening nothing in the Living thread in say 1-1½ hours the most?

You have phantom and Firefoot... and me. I solemnly swearto vote in the interests of the village.

(Or is that only believable when wolves say it?)

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by Rikae

You have phantom and Firefoot... and me. I solemnly swearto vote in the interests of the village.

(Or is that only believable when wolves say it?)

Haha. Aganzir I thought said she was going to hang around.

So three white riders (Firefoot, Agan & tp) against two dark wolves (Mac, Lottie) at the DL - and then you Rikae... interesting.

[the phantom]

At least they seem to realize that they need to act soon, but no one is being forceful about it. Someone needs to say, "The Dead HAVE to vote NOW because it's late. The voting plan is X. You have 30 minutes to say if anything is wrong with that vote plan. If not, that IS the plan no matter what anyone else says later. I have spoken."

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Originally Posted by Rikae

You have phantom and Firefoot... and me. I solemnly swearto vote in the interests of the village.

(Or is that only believable when wolves say it?)

Exactly the whole question is if that's enough. There is probably Aganzir at some at least decently late-ish point, but I am with Nog on that I would prefer to wrap this up, like, now.

Which, given there are zero votes on the Living thread and looking at the list of people who could vote for being in the European timezone, is not very nice. I expect Lommy to vote in a couple of hours because of her late-evening program together with Agan, and Mith and Eomer and Kath, if she appears, are still two hours in bonus compared to us near the lakes of Rhun. Others I expect to vote just before DL.

I'm wondering if I might even pull off some half-"doze of for two hours and possibly come back"-trick, but in that case I require somebody to be here and alert to give me a vote tally, and anyway, even with that I won't vote very close to the DL. (I could at least vote when there has actually a vote been cast.)

Or I might leave that be, which I do not like to do... or pull the same trick that's been discussed here before and inquire Aganzir here about alerting me by phone call in case my vote seems to be needed. But then again, it still would be probably too early before the DL, so it might not make sense at all.

[Rikae]

And, once again, being "helpful" by suggesting multiple plans... and known innocents are doing it, too.

Get your act together, living people!

Edit: X'd with Nog

[Rikae]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

You dead person!

Yes you,

exactly you who are reading this.


Please read this before you post anything!


We have a plan were trying to accomplish here. As we have no way to indicate the Living that they should lynch Boro (newcomer: we know McCaber was the last wolf) we try to do it by stopping our posting to 1588 replies.

So don't post anything on this thread for now!


This post is post number 1589 [EDIT: No, Because of Aganzir this is actually the post 1588 - but Aganzir's post is now 1589] – and if you check the ”Active Topics” or ”Middle-Earth Mirth” you can see the thread has 1588 replies. Hope you follow...


1588 replies.
Boromir88.


We'll stay silent until the last hours of the Day so that the Living might get the clue: nothing happens in the Dead thread for over half of the Day and the count stands at 1588.

The living might catch it or then they don't. Or some rebellious wolves might not wish to play along just in principle even if Boro is their enemy and the killer of their packmates. But we'll nevertheless wish to give this crazy plan a chance and to give this anniversary game the ending it deserves.


So do not post anything in this thread unless the Living have caught the message, or there is something like 5 to 7 hours of the Day left.

If you feel a need to say something, follow Agan's instructions of deleting one of your earlier posts to keep the post count intact.


Hold your horses!

PS. Read at least this page and the one before to understand how we came about this...

PS2 Let's keep the silence at least for this evening with the Americans - like 10 hours at least. Of course if the living start to think we think it's over, well of course we abandon the tactics (although I can't see why would they think that). I'm just afraid everyone doesn't remember to quote the plan-post and then some people get energized with a discussion and the plan is lost when someone comes into the middle of a discussion and hasn't seen this plan as it has gone up in the thread...

PS3. Although - a couple of posts - rarely made and including this basic message post might be good indeed during the Day if someone notices the discrepancy between the number of replies (1588) and the name of the last poster.

Morm, of course you can "see the deleted posts", they haven't been deleted, only consolidated into other posts with a note of where they originally were.
I was one of the people who called for rules against editing/deleting, and we all understood the purpose was to avoid deception about what was posted and when.
No one is engaging in such deception now.
I actually think your attempt to call what's being done now, cheating, is unsportsmanlike.

Originally Posted by Rikae

And, once again, being "helpful" by suggesting multiple plans... and known innocents are doing it, too.

Get your act together, living people!

Edit: X'd with Nog

And here is what I originally accidentally posted here:
EDIT: My post following this one:

Originally Posted by Rikae

Quote:
Originally Posted by Nogrod
How many "secure" voters do we have there at the DL against wolves aka. is there a good argument for early-sleepers not to vote at all if there seems to be happening nothing in the Living thread in say 1-1½ hours the most?

You have phantom and Firefoot... and me. I solemnly swearto vote in the interests of the village.

(Or is that only believable when wolves say it?)

EDIT - Stop it, phantom! By the time we got to 1688 they'd think we were proceeding as normal