Hobbit Trailer looks crap

[Inziladun]

Originally Posted by jallanite

The Harry Potter films were rather a shock to reviewers when they first started to appear, because author J. K. Rowling had full power over the directors to insist that no changes be made in the films over what was in the books, without her permission. The films accordingly followed the books very closely, leaving many reviewers to point out that this should not work, although it did.

On that point, in my opinion the first two HP movies are the best, and those are the most faithful to the books. Funny how that works.