Taters to Taters

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by the phantom

TOSS OUT
Alqualonde
Mumakil
Smaug
Goblin-town
Fellbeast

CONTENDERS
Morgoth- The mocking selection.
Watcher- The contradictory selection.
One Ring- The interesting selection.
Orome
Gimli
Celeborn- The in-the-moment silly selections.

I don't know how cunningly tp plays at this stage of the game, but I'd give you MCR an advice not to pick any of the last (aka. "the contenders") unless you want to give the phantom a three point lead...

Mumakil and Smaug are like the soft toys little children have - quite cuddly and huggable - and still in the books something completely different. I liked those choices. Gimli would come a close third to me.

Morgoth and The Watcher are already reaching out, like the Fellbeast (you don't make a "teddy-bear" -kind of thing from them that easily).

Towns are not "cuddly" - so people have been just discarding Red Taters they don't like or which don't seem to fit anywhere. Oromë and Celeborn sound more or less the same.

The One Ring? Well yes, that could make the "absurdometer" ring...


Someone asked who sent Denethor in the last round... well I did. It was so close but yet so far...