Meeting at the Town Cobbler (WW XCV game thread)

[Rikae]

Are you 100% sure I didn't dream Lottie as an ordo?

[Macalaure]

But if you dreamed of Lottie as an ordo, why is Eonwe not a steaming pile of hacked up meat at this point?

[satansaloser2005]

I am terribly sorry, everyone. My phone died about an hour ago and I only got it plugged in a few minutes ago.


The die rolled for neither Shasta nor Steve. Everyone remains at the Cobbler.


In the Cobbler:
Rikae
Lottie
Shasta
Mac
Steve


I'll get back to my computer later on. Thank you so much for your patience.

[Eönwë]

Originally Posted by Rikae

Are you 100% sure I didn't dream Lottie as an ordo?

Yes. Because I am an Ordo, and Sally said that there would be all the gifteds in this game, and none have died yet. And there's still one more wolf. Unless there's something that Sally's not telling us...

[Eönwë]

Well, on the one hand that's positive because it means we definitely get another Day, but on the other it's very bad, because we don't know anything new, and now there's no way of knowing everyone's role by toMorrow.

[Rikae]

Actually, Eönwë, you came out as "ordo" before I mentioned my fears concerning lynching the ranger, I believe, which argues in your favor because you had no way of knowing it was a safe role to claim.

Mac and Shasta implied they were ordos also, but later. Shasta, are you claiming ordo now? There is no benefit to hiding as the ranger at this point. It will be much simpler if we know what role is being claimed twice... Lottie should hunt one of those two, and it doesn't even matter that much which (what matters is that the real ranger has indeed stepped forward as such, so I can dream and see who is ordo and who is wolf).

Unfortunately I don't think Lottie is around.

[Rikae]

Or dream and see who is ranger or wolf as the case may be.

Yeah, it really doesn't matter which of the two Lottie hunts if one of Shasta and Eönwë is an ordo and the other a wolf: Mac and I could lynch the remaining wolf tommHour. So I'm not worried unless Lottie's not paying attention or Shasta is the ranger.

[Rikae]

(Just wanted to see your reaction to "not the hunter")

[Eönwë]

But now by doing this you're giving a possibly-wolvish Shasta a chance to choose to go against the Ranger or an Ordo. Why would you do that?

[Eönwë]

What I mean is that you should have chosen to let him reveal as what he wanted to, and then judged him. And does that mean you believe Mac's claim?

[Rikae]

If Shasta is a wolf...ish committe member, then you aren't, and it doesn't matter which he goes against, since tommHour is the last hour.

I believe Mac is not an ordo, and I believe you're not the ranger.

EDIT: Crossed with Shasta.

[Rikae]

Ok, going on the assumption that at this point no innocent has reason to lie about xer role:

Lottie, please hunt one of Shasta or Mac!


This way, tomorrow we'll have either:

Lottie
Mac - ranger or wolf
Shasta - ranger or wolf
Me - seer knowing the difference

or

Lottie
Steve
Shastawolf
Me

or

Stevewolf or Shastawolf
Mac
Me

And we'll win.

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Well, honestly, I was hoping to hide a little while longer - as long as it wasn't clear whether or not you were hiding Lottie's identity as the Ranger, the wolf might have guessed incorrectly with their kill tonight.

Hopefully that should clear things up. Now all you have to do is dream of Mac or I.

[Eönwë]

Happy now, Rikae?

edit: x-ed with Rikae herself.