Hin Hurin

[Urwen]

It's obvious where my loyalties lie... Even my username is also name of child of Hurin.

Long live Urwen and her glorious brother and sister! Especially sister.

Nienor.

Turin might have been slightly insane, and deserved to die at one point. But Nienor wasn't. Why did she have to die as well?

Morgoth,

For me and my two siblings, You must stop this madness.

Remember, I'm watching You from Void. I will hold You blameless if You stop this madness. Even though Your plague cost me my life.

Urwen (Lalaith)

[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

An interesting theory! So this Morgoth was spiteful, wasteful and wicked, you say?

[Pitchwife]

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

An interesting theory! So this Morgoth was spiteful, wasteful and wicked, you say?

What an outrageous suggestion! Next thing happening will be someone saying he was evil!

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by Pitchwife

What an outrageous suggestion! Next thing happening will be someone saying he was evil!

We probably shouldn't be daring as that, now sure we shouldn't? It's soo bad to judge people that easily. Surely there is an explanation, like his experiences as a youth (you know like banning from his family and friends and so on)?

[Urwen]

And that would be me. As they always say, you hate one who killed off your namesake.

Well, I hate the one who killed my namesake (and her family)

Namesakes are important, you know. They tell who you truly like.

Namesakes are your very essence. And as for my essence... Lalaith is mine.

And as a vivid fan of my namesake, her family is also important for me.

With Grief and Laugher, new day shall come.
Turin is not needed for our perfection to shine out,
alive, good and bright.

For Hin Hurin we are, and we know no fear.

We'll chase Morgoth till the Sun is in the rear





How do you like my poem? Told from POV of Urwen and Nienor

[Galadriel55]

I love all 3 Hini Hurin. And Hurin, and Morwen. Even though I'm neither's namesake. I still love them, and I love COH.
I think Morgoth was very clever when he cursed Hurin's kin. *You have to admit that, even though he's evil and hated by most characters*. Instead of torturing the faily to death with physical means, he causes them inner misery and grief. Also, instead of simply destroying all the strength that they posess, he uses it to help his own means. Or at least he meant to. Didn't really work out fully, but still worked. Remember how Morgoth was afraid that his curse will loose it's power, because Turin was so powerful? But no, all that good power was turned into something evil without Turin realizing what's aboard....

[Puddleglum]

Originally Posted by Galadriel55

Or at least he meant to. Didn't really work out fully, but still worked. (

When you think of Morgoth, think of one motivated and filled more and more by simple hate. Hate, especially, of anything and anyone that he cannot control and rule. That hate, while it hurt many others (including the family of Hurin) also had terrible impact on Morgoth himself. As he spent himself in hate, he lost the ability to alter his form (like the other Valar), became bound more and more to his own subterranean throne (until captured and bound by the host of the West - and expelled from the world), and raised up his own eventual destruction.

Tolkien wrote an interesting prophecy (of Mandos) dealing with the end of the world in which he notes that, in the final battle on the plains of Valinor, Turin will come from the Halls of Mandos and deal to Morgoth his final death and destruction.

That last is especially interesting since Turin is an Atani (man) and so it is significant that he is able to remain in the Halls of Mandos and refuse to leave the world - not just for a short time like Beren, but for the whole remaining history of Arda!! I've always felt that his determination and unwavering resolve to so remain were products of his treatment at the hands of Morgoth. Where his father eventually despaired of life and departed, Turin became so fixed in his determination to BE the "Master of Doom" that he was unwilling to depart. In the end, he became Illuvatar's tool in the final destruction of Morgoth.

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by Urwen

Turin might have been slightly insane, and deserved to die at one point. But Nienor wasn't. Why did she have to die as well?

Did he? Weren't all his unfortunes just because of the curse Morgoth made? Wasn't that the whole point; that everything he tried (but turning to Morgoth) were doomed to fail? Wasn't that the tragic of it all, that he should not bend but fight even if it went from bad to worse? And Nienor, sure, was a victim of the same curse. Neither had a fault of their own, but the curse hanging on them.

And those curses spanning over several generations are a frequent motive in many myths (including the Bible).

Oedipus didn't want to do bad but s**t happened. That's what tragedy is about?