WW LXXX: It's About Time!

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Agan

Eomer's relationship with Lottie and sally is interesting. He went after them both the same way, and it really seems improbable that he would have done that to a fellow... But he'd been suspected quite heavily, so it would kind of make sense to attack a fellow very hard so when one dies, at least the other looks better. Wouldn't be the first time that happens. But it's not just him who's being weird. They both attack him with very vague reasons while being totally sure of his guilt - and the certainty is sure to make them look better when Eomer turns out to be a wolf.

Yes, and it is rather weird how sure they were, even though he had been suspicious– yet, it seems like a very gratuitous bit of wolf-on-wolfing. Sally, was the one heavily pushing the idea that Greenie's innocence would prove Eomer's guilt, while Lottie practically dragged him to the gallows. Recall that all Wolf 3 had to do yesterDay was keep Eomer and the cobbler alive.

With you and Pitch, though, there's your Day 2 votes on Eomer, either of which might easily have killed him.

Of course, we know that wolf-on-wolfing of some kind happened, because everyone now living has accused and/or voted Eomer at some point.

So: "When you have eliminated the impossible..." Except not quite, because none of this is completely impossible. But I'd say– subject to revision– that the least improbable explanation is that you, Agan, are the cobbler, and Pitch is Wolf 3. If you made up your mind skip wasn't a wolf, you'd naturally want to steer the lynch his way, which you were trying to do yesterDay and the Day before. Meanwhile, on Day 2, you gave no strong indication you'd vote Eomer:

Originally Posted by Agan

I could go for sally, or maybe Lottie or even Eomer

So a Pitchwolf might have decided it was worth taking the risk of making a late wolf-on-wolf vote. His vote crossed with DL, and thus with yours.

That's my best-fit scenario at the moment.