LOTR grades - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Arwen Imladris · 10-23-2002, 02:12 PM

1- Sauron
2- Wormtongue
3- Gollum
4- Saruman
5- Boromir
6- Pippin
7- Bilbo
8- Merry/Eowyn
9- Gimli/ Legolas
10- Aragorn, Sam, Frodo, Faramir, Arwen
10 + (outstanding achievements): Gandalf/ Galadriel.

I would put Pippin and Merry together rather than Merry and Eowyn.
I would also put Aragorn, Sam and Frodo at a different level than Faramir and Arwen. It also depends on wether it is form the Movie or the Book, cause Arwen from the book is a house wife, I don't think that that would go over well for level 10.

In Ontario, we have this level system that has 4 levels. Level 1 is just barely better than failing and level 4 is beyond the expetations. What could a teacher use for that?

1-Sauron?
2-Golumm
3-legolas
4-Frodo

or
1- Sauron
1 Saruman
1+ Wormtong
2- Golumm
2 Denethor
2+ Boromir
3- Faramir
3 Gimli
3+ Legolas
4- Merry/Pippin
4 Aragorn
4+ Frodo
4++ Gandalf

What do you think?

10-23-2002, 02:12 PM	#3
Arwen Imladris Ghost Prince of Cardolan Join Date: Mar 2002 Location: In a box with a fox Posts: 1,347	1- Sauron 2- Wormtongue 3- Gollum 4- Saruman 5- Boromir 6- Pippin 7- Bilbo 8- Merry/Eowyn 9- Gimli/ Legolas 10- Aragorn, Sam, Frodo, Faramir, Arwen 10 + (outstanding achievements): Gandalf/ Galadriel. I would put Pippin and Merry together rather than Merry and Eowyn. I would also put Aragorn, Sam and Frodo at a different level than Faramir and Arwen. It also depends on wether it is form the Movie or the Book, cause Arwen from the book is a house wife, I don't think that that would go over well for level 10. In Ontario, we have this level system that has 4 levels. Level 1 is just barely better than failing and level 4 is beyond the expetations. What could a teacher use for that? 1-Sauron? 2-Golumm 3-legolas 4-Frodo or 1- Sauron 1 Saruman 1+ Wormtong 2- Golumm 2 Denethor 2+ Boromir 3- Faramir 3 Gimli 3+ Legolas 4- Merry/Pippin 4 Aragorn 4+ Frodo 4++ Gandalf What do you think? __________________ "Wake up! Wake up! Wake up, sleepies, we must go, yes, we must go at once."