Tol-in-Gaurhoth Threefold and Six: The Night Guard

[Nogrod]

I'm getting through the last two Days now but may throw some individual points to ask of people when I feel I'd like to hear some clarifications - or if I think the matter urgent enough to voice early enough...

Now what say you Pitchie about this?

Originally Posted by Pitchwife

So I'm inclined to think both Nog and Zil rather innocent at the moment, and I'm also inclined to look for the majority of our wolves among

* the supporters of The Plan and
* the Legate bandwagon.

It was early Days to be sure, but that's to the point... Were you trying to make people think it that way because you really thought that way yourself or did you try to make us think that way for some other reason?

I mean everyone should have realised at that point that "the plan" would have been good to us and not following it turned out a disaster. We should look at the opposers of the plan with scrutiny, not the proponents of it (well we should look at everyone but with this matter I'm inclined to suspect the opposition as it clearly was something that would have made the wolves take the pain). Yes, people don't always think things through and that's normal but we could try to see who was faking her/his confusion about the real stakes.

Also the Legate bandwagon was totally useless... well almost... but why did you want to think it that way like trying to sway the looks from the Inzil-voters?


Also with Boro I'm a bit uneasy with this kind of throw-aways:

Originally Posted by Boro

Nogrod, just because there was only one kill again last night, doesn't mean you are now automatically innocent. That one kill still makes you look suspicious in my eyes, the difference is now we know not to lynch someone based on those reasons alone. I'll be watching and waiting for your slip, be afraid, be very afraid.

First of all I don't think I never said I was innocent before this post (I think I said it toDay though) not to talk of me requiring you to think of me as one. Well I am innocent (second call), but I can't require you to believe me just by my word or by any dubious standard relating on how the wolves choose to play their game ot not. The problem with this is that you make it look like I have claimed innocense because of that Night's actions which I haven't and thence trying to claim something which basically a wolf would try to claim. But if you were a wolf wishing to see me lynched that would actually be the exact subtle way of trying it out whether others would pick on it.

Also this "be afraid!" or the latter "beware wolves, you've awakened the bear..." - with no consequences ever - look downright rhetorical, not genuine. Sorry.

But I see there have been a host of posts so let me quit for a while to read what has been said meanwhile...