Tol-in-Gaurhoth Threefold and Six: The Night Guard

[Pitchwife]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

I was just going to say, it would be a great joke if the pack consisted of Alona, Hakon, Nessa and Pitchwife, and what we've been seeing as some impenetrable masterplan is just the result of them being fairly inexperienced.

That would be very funny indeed - even more if we actually managed to win that way against you veterans! (And NO, that was NOT a confession, of course!)

Nog, isn't it obvious? If alona is a wolf, and is modfired, and we Guard or lynch a wolf, there will be 2 wolves left. If alona is innocent and modfired, and we Guard or lynch a wolf, 3 wolves left. So whatever alona's role, when she's modfired there will be 2-3 wolves left (unless she's innocent and we don't Guard or lynch a wolf -> 4 wolves left, but according to the Rules only one kill). What happened to your logic?

(x-ed with several Nerwensand Nogrods , and Boro.)

[Nogrod]

Okay, I'll end this speculation from my part right here... just after this

Originally Posted by Pitchwife

Nog, isn't it obvious? If alona is a wolf, and is modfired, and we Guard or lynch a wolf, there will be 2 wolves left. If alona is innocent and modfired, and we Guard or lynch a wolf, 3 wolves left. So whatever alona's role, when she's modfired there will be 2-3 wolves left (unless she's innocent and we don't Guard or lynch a wolf -> 4 wolves left, but according to the Rules only one kill). What happened to your logic?

See the bolding? Eönwë didn't give the option of there being 4 left but said there would be 2-3 left. That's what bothers me there.

Okay, maybe it was meant to be there was 2-3 wolves "free to act" during the Night... But just saying x wolves left brings different ideas to mind. And as even one wolf can kill during the Night so why make that declaration in the first place?

Okay, that's it for me now...