WWLXII: Dead Men Do Tell Tales

[Thinlómien]

Sally's interactions with those who still live

Eönwë
Day1 he banters with her, she thinks he is ok
Day3 he thinks she's innocent
Day4 he votes her
Day6 chatter

Gwath
Day1 she banters with him on Day, she says: "nothing on him, except that I like to rib him"
Day3 he questions Rikae over her
Day4 she wouldn't like to vote him to save herself, she votes him
Day7 he calls her a cobbler

Izzy
Day1 S has nothing about I
Day2 I accuses S on Day2, I debates voting S
Day3 I suspects S for the quick vote , I keeps suspecting S, I suspects S yet more
Day4 I is very suspicious of S
Day5 I notes it's interesting to see S is more active when dead

Nerwen
Day1 S doesn't suspect N on
Day4 N points a possible slip from S, N says S and Gwath can't be mutineers togethe
Day5 talk about Kath, slight suspicion back and forth
Day6 chat about N's misreadings
Day7 N says S has confessed she's evil

Shasta
Day1 she calls him "power-hungry son of a sea w(hor[s]e)", she votes him and gives him the second vote
Day3 she votes him right when the Day starts,
Day4 he is unsure about the wagon against her, he doesn't like her possibly trying to manipulate him, he votes her


Mac's interactions with those who still live

Eönwë
Day1 M lists E as "more innocent than guilty"
Day2 M lists E under "simply no idea"
Day3 E likes the stuff M's done, M has E leaning towards innocent
Day4 M says E is probably innocent
Day5 M says E needs a closer look, M says E is worth a raised eyebrow for being unreasonable
Day6 M has a bad feeling about E, M makes a really straw-grasping case on E and proclaims him guilty, E says M has started to look a little suspicious, M suspects the wolf pack consists of E + Lommy + Gwath, M thinks Lommy defending E is mutineer defending a fellow, E calls M Boromir under the influence of the Ring, E wonders about the M-Lommy argument, E votes M
Day7 E speculates rather thoroughly about possible M-scenarios, E votes M but mentions his retraction but then clarifies it's very unlikely he'll retract, M is confused about him

Gwath
Day1 talk about whether there'll be a double-lynch on, M lists G as "clueless" and wonder about his contribution, M dismisses the option of giving G a second vote based on his cluelessness
Day2 talk about whether to believe Greenie , M doesn't find G's vote suspicious on, G asks M to explain his vote
Day3 M wants to have another look at G, M suspects G on Annu is mutineer-on-mutineer, G answers M's suspicion, M says to G "while I agree that the other people voting for you may not have the best reasons, I'm afraid I still suspect you more than the rest o' the crew", M votes G
Day4 M is suspicious of G, M votes G
Day5 M thinks G had a reason to suspect he'd be picked by Rikae , M comments the votes: "Gwath is in the lead?? Yikes!"
Day6 M wonders if G'll be back since he's alive according to the lists, M is sure about G's guilt, M suspects the wolf pack consists of G + Lommy + Eönwë, M speculates about G's guilt
Day7 G needs more reading to determine whether M is ordo or wolf, G votes M, M decides G's innocent after all because he considered M was telling the truth

Izzy
Day1 he lists her under "clueless"
Day2 she accuses him, he lists her under "simply no idea", she remarks he's voting alongside a suspect of his, she debates voting him, she votes him
Day3 she wonders about him and Nog, she doesn't alarm him, she doesn't like him
Day4 he's fine with her, he thinks she didn't have a reason to suspect being picked by the hunter
Day5 she considers voting him, he says she's probably not a wolf but may be a cobbler
Day6 she debates voting him, he doubts she's a mutineer, she votes him, she says her vote signifies he's a mutineer, she thinks both he and Lommy are mutineers, he claims to have protected her, he tries to sweet-talk her to his side, she reatracts her vote for him
Day7 she rebukes him for twisting the truth, she says "Mac is... Mac"

Nerwen
Day1 he lists her under "clueless" and claims he won't be able to read her, he dismisses the option of giving her a second vote based on his cluelessness
Day2 he takes her word for Nog because of her known innocence on, he lists her as almost known innocent
Day3 he thinks Eomer's death solidates her innocence, she says he's speaking sense, she wonders if he and Nog are in cahoots
Day4 he calls her a quasi-known innocent, he explains her deathlessness, she says his guilt can't be ruled out because of Rikae's suspicion of him
Day6 he says she's probably innocent, she votes him, she wonders if his claim has credit, she retracts her vote for him and saves him
Day7 she speculates in which cases a wolf-Mac would be so resigned, she votes him

Shasta
Day1 M lists S as "more guilty than innocent"
Day2 S says "An' he keeps 'em pearly white, Mac." (no idea what he's referring to!), M's reply is "An' ye be keepin' it out of sight, I reckon?", M says S is getting "worked up" so he's probably innocent, M is doubtful about S and thinks he may be a cobbler
Day3 M thinks S may be a co-consp but nothing worse
Day4 M keeps saying S may be a cobbler, M reminds S that the vote is up to him
Day5 S thinks M+Lommy stuff is staged, M says S has slipped his attention, M says S is too much in the shadows but genuinely helpful, S repeats suspicion of a stage act, M asks S who he's going to vote
Day6 S asks M to clarify stuff, M feels good about S, S thinks both M and Lommy are mutineers, S believes M's ranger claim, S defends M's claim
Day7 S is unsure about M, S is tempted to vote M but still unsure

And that's it. Thoughts coming in a separate post, this is too long already.


edit: mass-xed