WWLXII: Dead Men Do Tell Tales

[Gwathagor]

Originally Posted by Thinlómien

I'm here...

I think Shasta is the evil one. Truly, Eönwë and Gwath sound honest to me, Izzy is a cobbler and trusting Greenie and what I'm seeing, I think Nerwen is probably an innocent (*sigh* I wish she'd been a cobbler, I'd feel much better about getting lynched).

I think we've caught three baddies this far, I have no idea who the third is, but two of the mutineers were Sally and Mac, I could bet a lot on that. So, as soon as I have the time, I will look through their posts and look for clues and see if my Shasta-hypothesis rings true or if someone else comes out looking worse...

What gives you the idea we've caught three? Is it statistics, or just a theory? Why do you think Shasta is the fourth?

Originally Posted by Eönwë

I need to go. I will hopefully be back before DL (If Brinn extends it by an hour or more), but just in case, I'll make it official:

++Shasta

Eonwe, it kind of looks like you just pick up on whatever suspicion has recently been suggested and vote on it. Or did you give some reason somewhere for why you're voting Shasta and I just missed it?