WWLXII: Dead Men Do Tell Tales

[Eönwë]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

#60. (To Cowerin' Gwath Slasher– he were a-threatenin' of her fer callin' him a powder-monkey, which he be, the lubber!)

'Twas fer callin' 'im Gwathy I believe. Sez so in t'quote ye give.


Jus' sayin'...

Originally Posted by Rikae

What worries me now, tho', are th' reactions t' th' drunk - p'ticklarly Eonwe n' Inziladun's, because o' t' way they latch onto th' idea o' a co-conspirator (ef I be readin' them right) revealin' later

What that be meanin'? I sed was 'tat if she be not th' real spy then th' real spy probly not be revealin' so early, so we'll 'ave t' make sho' tha' we don' trust Greenie too much. We'll may 'ave t' accept 'er as th' spy (if there be no counter-claims), but what i'm sayin' is not to place all yer trust in 'er, as she may be a-lyin'.

An' latch on? I was th' first 'un to say th't she may not be th' spy.

Originally Posted by Boromir88

We know Greenie's be 'acked by the mutineers, which mean she most likely be good, an' even if she be a co-conspier'ator, it would be no use in lynchin' her at 'tis point when no one else has said they be the spy. I say we trus' her, which means fer now I also trust Nerwen...I s'pose 'tis possible she be a co-conspie, but thar be no reason to doubt Greenie, at 'tis point, an' thus Nerwen too is not a mutineer. Nerwen's status could change, dependin' on Greenie's role, an' other behaviors, but fer now...if ye trus' Greenie, I be trustin' Nerwen. Thar be no sense in lynchin' either o' them today.

How does tha' work? Greenie sed she ha' no dream. So that be a-helpin' Nerwen's case?

[Rikae]

Ok, Eon, I see ye were sayin' th' opposite o' what I thought. But now I have a question -

Originally Posted by Eonwe

I sed was 'tat if she be not th' real spy then th' real spy probly not be revealin' so early, so we'll 'ave t' make sho' tha' we don' trust Greenie too much.

Why wouldn't th' real spy reveal right away? She'd be dead, so what would she have t' lose, savvy?

[Rikae]

Kath, go back an' look at what I say in me vote post. I think what Shasta did was worse than "advocating a double lynch". I ne'er said he did, so whose words 'r bein' a-twisted now, eh?

Eonwe, Green did claim that she dreamed o' Nerwen an' found her not an aggressor.

EDIT: X'd w' Wilwa n' Shasta

[Rikae]

Eonwe's mistake makes 'im look a little more innocent t' me.

[Eönwë]

Originally Posted by Rikae

Why wouldn't th' real spy reveal right away? She'd be dead, so what would she have t' lose, savvy?

Because they'd want time to get more dreams.

Originally Posted by Rikae

KathEonwe, Green did claim that she dreamed o' Nerwen an' found her not an aggressor.

Ok yes. I'm sorry about that. I misread her posts.

Originally Posted by Kath

Eonwe - I'm slightly confused. Seems to say that if Greenie is not the spy then the real one won't reveal so we should take what Greenie says with a pinch of salt ... but then says the wolves were either very lucky or good. Just sort of seems to go against his own point.

The second part is only applicable if she really was the spy.

edit: fixed first quote

[Rikae]

Originally Posted by Eönwë

Because they'd want time to get more dreams.

Methinks dead seers don't dream.

[Eönwë]

Originally Posted by Rikae

Methinks dead seers don't dream.

The real one'd still be alive (unless it's Cabbie).