WWLXII: Dead Men Do Tell Tales

[Boromir88]

I have a feelin' (in me wooden leg) that tha's gonna be exactly what we'll have to do, if we wanna get out o' this alive. I'm just hopin' that we do it once, at the right time, an' make it count.~Rikae

We ha'e an accord. Howe'er do we gun for a rat ob'iously makin' trouble, or someone who be a 'lil more sneaky about it? Cause we do not want to waste it on one o' the cobblers, an' me bet the cobblers would be lookin' to be sent t' Davey Jones' locker twice, if ye know what me mean.

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by Boro-gun

Whar is the fire, Nogrod? Whar is the passion in yer belly?

Lost. I've had time to look at this thread about a half an hour in total toDay (and all this nonsense - even if funny - doesn't help forming opinions) - and lately I have been writing Arda Soccer results - and now it's 5AM and I need to go to sleep. Sorry mates. Bad day for werewolfing.

But I need to vote as well... and give it some thought before doing it.

[Rikae]

Originally Posted by Boromir88

We ha'e an accord. Howe'er do we gun for a rat ob'iously makin' trouble, or someone who be a 'lil more sneaky about it? Cause we do not want to waste it on one o' the cobblers, an' me bet the cobblers would be lookin' to be sent t' Davey Jones' locker twice, if ye know what me mean.

We best wait n' see. I be thinkin' it might help us if we have, fer instance, two ghosts claimin' t' be t' seer - or mebbe some other, unforeseen circumstances. At some point, if we're lucky, some solid information'll be all we need to catch us some mutineers.

[Nogrod]

I don't think we need to speculate on that Boro. Like Rikae said we'll see about that. It's interesting you're calling for debate but can only give us that?

Anyways. We need to leave Boro - among some others for the baddies to kill so we can trust them as ghosts or then wonder why they're still alive on Day4 or something... and then make them mutineers walk the plank if needs be.

So I will make my choice on these premises toDay. Someone says that's suitable for me... well be my guests. It will be maddening and pointless for many Days as we will learn nothing from anything that is done. The only minor opportunity is to listen to those who are killed by Night and thinking about why they were killed (as there is no voting trace to be read or anything like that), but even those can be them bloody cobblers - and the baddies will think it through as well...

I don't like to surrender without a fight but our future is gloomy at best with these settings. What way do we have to catch anyone unless they really make epic fails or we somehow get enough of them with luck in the first Days so that we'll have the advance in numbers in the longer run?

But we shall fight those vermins anyway, whatever the odds be! Arm the guns! And aim steadily!

[Macalaure]

Vote count:

Rikae -> Inziladun
Eomer -> Mirandir
Boro -> Nogrod
Kath -> Eonwe
Shasta -> Boro
Eonwe -> Rikae
Little Green -> Shasta
Lommy -> McCaber
Wilwa -> Little Green

Arrr! Are ye be foolin' me? One vote for each? Are we going to ensure that the mutineers get the most possible voting power?

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by Macalaure

Arrr! Are ye be foolin' me? One vote for each? Are we going to ensure that the mutineers get the most possible voting power?

Exactly my words... but who's to throw the second stone? (Those votes in are the safest there are, remember that later)

Okay, I'll take a look back and vote in - hopefully - a half an hour (it's getting early already in here).

And where's everyone when decisions should be made?

Oh you cowards! I wouldn't sign anyone of you to my ship if I ever had one!

[Macalaure]

More innocent than guilty:

Rikae - very Rikae-ish so far, hard to explain
Lommy - I usually have a good read on her, and so far I like what I see
Inziladun
Boro - same opinion on Nogrod as me, which doesn't mean much, but is enough to put him on this list for toDay
Eomer
Kath
Lil' Green
Eonwe


Clueless:

Sally
Wilwa
Annu
Nerwen - I don't pretend anymore that I could ever get a clue about her
Gwath - he's contributing? On Day 1?
Mirandir
Izzy
Mith


More guilty than innocent:

Nogrod - see above
Shasta - don't like his vote
McCaber

[Macalaure]

Let's cast a second stone, shall we?

++Nogrod

[Inziladun]

Right. Thar's still not much t' go on, to my way o' thinkin'. I be goin' t' th' bunk right soon, so's a vote has t' come now.
McCaber popped in at th' day's dawnin' n' right away condemned ol' Shasta fer bein' the second in command n' standin' ta' benefit th' most from the poor Cap'n's head bein' detached. He's not been seen since to offer anythin' more.
A thin case may be, but thin's all I see t' work w' now.

++ McCaber

Edit-x'd with Nogrod and Rikae

[Nogrod]

Here would be the easy-going ones... (numbers being the number of posts - and Izzy has not posted but I'd give her the benefit of doubt at least now as it's possible she doesn't just know the game is on)

Mithalwen 2
Annunfuiniel 2
Eomer of the Rohirrim 2
wilwarin538 2
Mirandir 1
McCaber 1
satansaloser2005 1

I hate it everytime someone who would actually play gets lynched and those not interested (or ready to make an effort) get by Day1's.

Mith seemed to be in a rush even if I felt some bad vibes with her from a long time.

Annu is new to the game if veteran to the 'Downs and I'd give her my benefit of doubt as well.

Eomer has been just downright calculating and should be hanged for that - and for his general "get away from Day1 problems by just not posting" -attitude. But I'm also knowledgeable that he can be of help later - even if we really should lynch him a couple of times just to force him to play also on Day1 - and we could start on this Day...

wilwa... well, not too good either. Underlining that her vote was random, completely random even - and saying she'd be better on Day2! What better way for a baddie to skip the scrutiny and the chance of getting lynched on Day1 which is - to be sure - the saddest result for a baddie in a team.

Mira has one post worth nothing. Out for a "few hours" eight hours ago? Okay, that might be for real as she would probably not have said that were she a wolf trying to avoid attention and then break her promise in that obvious way (so a bored ordo who doesn't give the heck to this?).

McCaber sent the first post of the Day and never returned... Suspicious but maybe even too obvious? Anyway I don't like it.

Sally made one as well. Just as crazy as she is. I may feel a bit more relaxed with her than with some others as she actually seemed to be in a hurry.