Game Thread: Werewolf- this time it's real!

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Well, at the very least we have delayed what Nogrod feared the baddies intend to do.

Brinniel's 'reveal' gave the village another DAY. Oft evil shall evil mar!

And finally, Kent, after two DAYs you answer my suspicions! Care to answer why you think us suspicious, though? Be you special?

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

The DAY 3 vote list (times in GMT +8; known innocents underlined, known baddies emphasised):

• 04:54 Kent - Brinn (+1)
  Brinn - 2
  
  
• 05:23 Sally - Kent
  Brinn - 2, Kent - 1
  
  
• 07:01 Green - Nog
  Brinn - 2, Kent - 1, Nog - 1
  
  
• 08:38 Fea - Nog
  Brinn - 2, Kent - 1, Nog - 2
  
  
• 11:02 Shasta - Gwath
  Brinn - 2, Kent - 1, Nog - 2, Gwath - 1
  
  
• 12:39 Gwath - Sally
  Brinn - 2, Kent - 1, Nog - 2, Gwath - 1, Sally - 1
• 12:40 Form - Brinn (+3)
  Brinn - 6, Kent - 1, Nog - 2, Gwath - 1, Sally - 1
• 12:41 Lari - Nog (+3)
  Brinn - 6, Kent - 1, Nog - 6, Gwath - 1, Sally - 1
  
  
• 12:45 Kuru - Brinn (+6)
  Brinn - 13, Kent - 1, Nog - 6, Gwath - 1, Sally - 1
  
  
• 12:57 Nilp - Brinn (+4) (no highlight)
  Brinn - 13, Kent - 1, Nog - 6, Gwath - 1, Sally - 1
  
  
• 01:00 Izzy - Sally
  Brinn - 13, Kent - 1, Nog - 6, Gwath - 1, Sally - 2
• 01:00 Brinn - Nog (+10)
  Brinn - 13, Kent - 1, Nog - 17, Gwath - 1, Sally - 2

Did not vote: Nilpaurion Felagund. (invalid vote)

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Even though we already have a known baddie, the fact the she was merely the Cobbler, instead of being one of the Three, makes it less useful to analysis. However, someone with more time can perhaps scrutinise her posts to find some clues into what she thought. Cobblers looking for their masters can be rather astute.

YesterDAY's voting has been interesting in some aspects, one of which was Izzy's vote: Voting for Sally at the last minute even without the chance of lynching her. Of course, it could be a principles thing, and ordos have been known to do that; nevertheless it certainly is interesting.

Which brings me to another point: bonus votes. There are still four who have all 10, one of whom I suspect, and two of which are quiet. I am inclined to think Green and Shasta innocent, Gwath somewhat suspicious, and I believe Sally is t3h evil.

Back to the yesterDAY's vote: Fea's vote post. I thought it cobblery, but since it has been subsequently revealed that she is not the Cobbler, could she be one of the Three, then?

Will vote in my next post.

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

We still have Lúthien. She is still dreaming. The Cobbler has bought us a DAY to get a Wolf. We still can win this, village.

With this (likely) last post for toDAY, I shall vote:

++satansaloser2005 (+4)

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

No, Nilp. Not one of the three. I decided to experiment with the phantom's trick of using the best trick ordos have: make yourself into a target to keep eyes off of more important players. I figured if the wolves were settled on me being a cobbler, they'd kill somebody else off in the night: hopefully the cobbler. I didn't expect it to actually work, but it's worth a shot when you've got no clue what you're doing otherwise.

[Kent2010]

And finally, Kent, after two DAYs you answer my suspicions! Care to answer why you think us suspicious, though? Be you special?
-Nilp

I consider any one of you 3 capable of lynching me at the first oppurtunity you get.

Why didn't I respond earlier, what was I to respond to? Being your 'secret suspect,' it's like trying to respond to Sally saying she thinks I'm a rat. It's a pointless statement and would have been more pointless to respond. If you were trying to look like Luthien, if you are innocent you should give up, the baddies didn't buy it because I'm not one of them.

What does get me suspicious of you is your chivalry regarding Brinn yesterday. Saying you would not highlight your vote since Brinn said she was Finrod. It looks like a nice gesture, but it would be more beneficial to take care of Finrod at night, because Finrod can't protect himself and you can have an assured kill. You kill two for one...Nogrod gets lynched, because of your chivalry in saving Brinn, but if you believed she was Finrod it would be better to deal with Finrod at night. However, baddies got fooled by their own cobbler, hehe.

[A Little Green]

Fea (6) - I don't know what to think about her. I find her toDay's post both innocentish and fishy. The explanation she gives makes sense, but it just crossed my mind that Fea is smart enough to pull that sort of thing off as a wolf and that it would be quite a clever move for a wolf - after all, behaving as weirdly as she has done doesn't quite look like what is generally considered wolvish behaviour.

Formendacil (7) - Still nothing to make my alarm bells ringing.

Gwath (10) - Under the reindeer.

Izzy (8) - Same thing. I'm interested in her yesterDay's vote that seems much like a throwaway to me.

Kent (4) - Innocentish still.

Lari (7) - Under the reindeer.

Nilp (7) - Kent brings up a good point about his voting yesterDay. I won't, however, shut out the possibility that he is just an ordo who believed what Brinn said about being Finrod. Other than that, I don't know. I need to look at him as well as those under-the-reindeer people.

Sally (10) - I'm beginning to feel uneasy about Sally. She seems slippery, probably because the little she says is very unspecific. Like these:

Originally Posted by Sally

Brinn makes me giggle, but in a 'I know how you feel, you poor girl' sort of way. I really don't want to see her go toDay because while it's possible she's guilty (which is a possibility for all of you, so that really means nothing, dang it) I'd like to hear more from her so I can get a better read on the girl.

Kent still makes me uneasy, just in general. I don't know what exactly it is, but a lot of the things he's said have made me uneasy and while I don't want to kill him just to find out what he is I'm not going to complain if he ends up dead at the end of the Day, because I keep smelling a Kent....erm, rat.

Nog seems genuine and yet at the same time I know I can't read him, so when I trust Nog completely he's generally got something up his sleeve.

I actually just looked through Izzy's posts (was looking for a quote which in the end I don't think she even said, alas) and think she may be sliding down to my innocent list. We don't exactly see eye to eye, but that doesn't mean she's evil, and after seeing a couple things she's said I'll have to give her some more thought.

This sort of "s/he is kind of suspicious and kind of not" -comments are ideal for a baddie since they can be used either way in the future.

Shasta (10) - Nothing rings my alarm bells about him at the moment.

ToDay, if I have the time, I'll have a look at at least one of those people who are lurking under my reindeer. Probably Izzy, since she's the one of them who I feel most uneasy about - that partly because she escapes everyone's attention even though she's participating quite actively.