Hurt and Heal Hobbit Edition - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Aganzir · 04-10-2009, 01:49 PM

Nog I agree with you but that was an evil choice!

Heal Frodo, hurt Teddy & Sméagol.

Smeagol (7)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (9)
Sam (11)
Merry (10)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (10)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (8)
Lobelia (11)
Deagol (9)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (11)
Ted Sandyman (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

the phantom · 04-10-2009, 01:56 PM

I agree to a certain extent Nog, but I just finished rereading "Hobbit" recently and I'm rereading "Fellowship" now, and Bilbo is just so darn likable and funny and smart and cool. I may not support him to the bitter end, and may favor a lesser known character, but the fact remains that no way do I want to see him gone before some of these other people. Do we really think being a minor character alone makes one worthy of winning the trophy?

Hurt Lotho, Hurt Deagol, Heal Sancho

Smeagol (7)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (9)
Sam (11)
Merry (10)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (10)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (7)
Lobelia (11)
Deagol (8)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (11)
Ted Sandyman (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

mormegil · 04-10-2009, 03:16 PM

Heal Nob Double hurt Frodo

Smeagol (7)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (7)
Sam (11)
Merry (10)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (7)
Lobelia (11)
Deagol (8)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (11)
Ted Sandyman (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

Tuor in Gondolin · 04-10-2009, 03:35 PM

Hurt Rory Brandybuck Hurt Lotho S-B Heal Ted Sandyman

Smeagol (7)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (7)
Sam (11)
Merry (10)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (6)
Lobelia (11)
Deagol (8)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)
__________________

Kent2010 · 04-10-2009, 03:40 PM

Hurt Smeagol and Pimple

Heal Frodo

Smeagol (6)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (8)
Sam (11)
Merry (10)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (5)
Lobelia (11)
Deagol (8)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

Aganzir · 04-10-2009, 04:06 PM

Heal Lobelia, hurt Rosie and Teddy.

Smeagol (6)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (8)
Sam (11)
Merry (10)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (5)
Lobelia (12)
Deagol (8)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

the phantom · 04-10-2009, 04:11 PM

Double Hurt Deagol, Heal Bullroarer

Smeagol (6)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (8)
Sam (11)
Merry (10)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (5)
Lobelia (12)
Deagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

04-10-2009, 01:49 PM	#1
Aganzir Woman of Secret Shadow Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: in hollow halls beneath the fells Posts: 4,511	Nog I agree with you but that was an evil choice! Heal Frodo, hurt Teddy & Sméagol. Smeagol (7) Bilbo (10) Frodo (9) Sam (11) Merry (10) Pippin (10) The Gaffer (11) Farmer Maggot (11) Fatty Bolger (10) Nob (10) Rosie Cotton (10) Farmer Cotton (10) Lotho S-B (8) Lobelia (11) Deagol (9) Mayor Will Whitfoot (10) Bandobras Took (10) Rory Brandybuck (11) Ted Sandyman (5) Sancho Proudfoot (10) __________________ He bit me, and I was not gentle.

04-10-2009, 01:56 PM	#2
the phantom Beloved Shadow Join Date: Jul 2002 Location: The Stadium Posts: 5,971	I agree to a certain extent Nog, but I just finished rereading "Hobbit" recently and I'm rereading "Fellowship" now, and Bilbo is just so darn likable and funny and smart and cool. I may not support him to the bitter end, and may favor a lesser known character, but the fact remains that no way do I want to see him gone before some of these other people. Do we really think being a minor character alone makes one worthy of winning the trophy? Hurt Lotho, Hurt Deagol, Heal Sancho Smeagol (7) Bilbo (10) Frodo (9) Sam (11) Merry (10) Pippin (10) The Gaffer (11) Farmer Maggot (11) Fatty Bolger (10) Nob (10) Rosie Cotton (10) Farmer Cotton (10) Lotho S-B (7) Lobelia (11) Deagol (8) Mayor Will Whitfoot (10) Bandobras Took (10) Rory Brandybuck (11) Ted Sandyman (5) Sancho Proudfoot (11) __________________ the phantom has posted. This thread is now important.

04-10-2009, 03:16 PM	#3
mormegil Maundering Mage Join Date: Apr 2005 Location: Texas Posts: 4,651	Heal Nob Double hurt Frodo Smeagol (7) Bilbo (10) Frodo (7) Sam (11) Merry (10) Pippin (10) The Gaffer (11) Farmer Maggot (11) Fatty Bolger (10) Nob (11) Rosie Cotton (10) Farmer Cotton (10) Lotho S-B (7) Lobelia (11) Deagol (8) Mayor Will Whitfoot (10) Bandobras Took (10) Rory Brandybuck (11) Ted Sandyman (5) Sancho Proudfoot (11) __________________ “I wish it need not have happened in my time," said Frodo. "So do I," said Gandalf, "and so do all who live to see such times. But that is not for them to decide. All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us.”

04-10-2009, 03:35 PM	#4
Tuor in Gondolin Ghost Prince of Cardolan Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: Southeast Pennsylvania Posts: 3,651	Hurt Rory Brandybuck Hurt Lotho S-B Heal Ted Sandyman Smeagol (7) Bilbo (10) Frodo (7) Sam (11) Merry (10) Pippin (10) The Gaffer (11) Farmer Maggot (11) Fatty Bolger (10) Nob (11) Rosie Cotton (10) Farmer Cotton (10) Lotho S-B (6) Lobelia (11) Deagol (8) Mayor Will Whitfoot (10) Bandobras Took (10) Rory Brandybuck (10) Ted Sandyman (6) Sancho Proudfoot (11) __________________ __________________ The poster formerly known as Tuor of Gondolin. Walking To Rivendell and beyond 12,555 miles passed Nt./Day 5: Pass the beacon on Nardol, the 'Fire Hill.'

04-10-2009, 03:40 PM	#5
Kent2010 Wight Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: USA Posts: 240	Hurt Smeagol and Pimple Heal Frodo Smeagol (6) Bilbo (10) Frodo (8) Sam (11) Merry (10) Pippin (10) The Gaffer (11) Farmer Maggot (11) Fatty Bolger (10) Nob (11) Rosie Cotton (10) Farmer Cotton (10) Lotho S-B (5) Lobelia (11) Deagol (8) Mayor Will Whitfoot (10) Bandobras Took (10) Rory Brandybuck (10) Ted Sandyman (6) Sancho Proudfoot (11) __________________ an eye for an eye leaves everyone blind

04-10-2009, 04:06 PM	#6
Aganzir Woman of Secret Shadow Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: in hollow halls beneath the fells Posts: 4,511	Heal Lobelia, hurt Rosie and Teddy. Smeagol (6) Bilbo (10) Frodo (8) Sam (11) Merry (10) Pippin (10) The Gaffer (11) Farmer Maggot (11) Fatty Bolger (10) Nob (11) Rosie Cotton (9) Farmer Cotton (10) Lotho S-B (5) Lobelia (12) Deagol (8) Mayor Will Whitfoot (10) Bandobras Took (10) Rory Brandybuck (10) Ted Sandyman (5) Sancho Proudfoot (11) __________________ He bit me, and I was not gentle.

04-10-2009, 04:11 PM	#7
the phantom Beloved Shadow Join Date: Jul 2002 Location: The Stadium Posts: 5,971	Double Hurt Deagol, Heal Bullroarer Smeagol (6) Bilbo (10) Frodo (8) Sam (11) Merry (10) Pippin (10) The Gaffer (11) Farmer Maggot (11) Fatty Bolger (10) Nob (11) Rosie Cotton (9) Farmer Cotton (10) Lotho S-B (5) Lobelia (12) Deagol (6) Mayor Will Whitfoot (10) Bandobras Took (11) Rory Brandybuck (10) Ted Sandyman (5) Sancho Proudfoot (11) __________________ the phantom has posted. This thread is now important.