Tol-in-Gaurhoth LVII - Chess Game for Middle Earth: Game Thread

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Isabellkya

Question Sally.
If you were in contact with Kath like you say - then why did you follow her in lynching an innocent Hansy?

At the time I hadn't been dreamed, or rather I'd been dreamed but I wasn't a gifted at the time so she couldn't PM me. And she hadn't dreamed Hansy yet, so even if I had been talking to her it would have only been our hunches, not actual information.

AND I thought he was guilty.


Why exactly is it bad to follow the seer again?


Wait. Why am I even responding to Izzy?

[Rikae]

Originally Posted by Mnemo

Rikae

Originally Posted by Mnemo

, your plan sounds good, but I still don't want to do anything even remotely trust-like until you give whatever explanation you have for the Day Two lynch. And it may be none. If I'm going along and believing sally here that means that I must fully expect our Noble Mod to mess with our heads. But. I'd still like your thoughts on the matter. If Izzy is as guilty as you say, why was she saved?

Might there be another gifted role?

I thought I was answering before - specifically, when I said "you actually have a good point". That's part of what made me rethink Sally - there is obviously something going on in this game I don't know about. I do know that Izzy's survival was the survival of a wolf, but that's it.

Something that did occur to me was that the black knight might have the ability to protect during a lynch under some circumstance... or, like Sally said, maybe the Black Queen had something to do with it. Izzy being evil, an evil explanation makes some sense.

[Mnemosyne]

Okay, Rikae, thanks for clarifying.

I am inclined to trust you for the rest of toDay.

Though it'd be awful if wilwa (who said she may not be able to make it on for the rest of the Day) were the real WQ and thus can't reveal.

[Mnemosyne]

And the black knight lynch-protecting would make some sense as well.

[Brinniel]

Ooh, a false reveal. I was wondering when this was going to happen.



Now I think I know two Black pieces. And if we can eliminate them, then we'll be cutting our enemies in half. A very good outlook indeed so long as the rest of us won't let the baddies convince us otherwise.

Originally Posted by Mnemo

Though it'd be awful if wilwa (who said she may not be able to make it on for the rest of the Day) were the real WQ and thus can't reveal.

If wilwa were the WQ and around, should she reveal? It might be a good idea for the WQ to remain in the shadows unless her own life is being threatened.

(Okay I have this nasty headache and am feeling a bit dizzy right now, so bear with me. I'm trying to keep up despite the pain...but three pages in the few hours I was gone? Good grief. )