Tol-in-Gaurhoth LVII - Chess Game for Middle Earth: Game Thread

[the phantom]

Originally Posted by Sally

So clever clogs Phantom pants, I want to hear your theory on me, since you said it may have changed or whatever toward the end of the Day. Do tell.

Oh, I had many theories about you.

1) She's a WW and wants everyone to believe she's a Cobbler.

2) She's the BQ, and thinks we should let her live so she can kill that WW she failed to kill last night.

3) She's the WQ, and she can be lynched today, but if we leave her till tomorrow she can change her Lynch-Protect pick (I was assuming the WQ had this power) to herself, thus her statement that we were free to lynch her the next day.

4) She's the Black Rook and was protected during the Night, and so wants to at least survive the lynch as she figures she'll be dying that Night anyway.

5) She's a white piece of some sort, and is attempting to Cobbler fish (look guilty and see who jumps in to help her).

6) She's the Cobbler and wants everyone to think she's a WW pretending to be the Cobbler.

7) She has a secret role that no one knows about.

8) She is just being stupid because she had a bad day and wants to annoy everyone.

9) She was accidentally PMed by Shasta with everyone's Role, and so cannot fairly play any more, and she's just wasting time and messing around and has secretly been removed from the tally.

As you can see, the theories got a little desperate at the end. Though it's completely possible that I just made up those last couple.

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by the phantom

Oh, I had many theories about you.

1) She's a WW and wants everyone to believe she's a Cobbler.

2) She's the BQ, and thinks we should let her live so she can kill that WW she failed to kill last night.

3) She's the WQ, and she can be lynched today, but if we leave her till tomorrow she can change her Lynch-Protect pick (I was assuming the WQ had this power) to herself, thus her statement that we were free to lynch her the next day.

4) She's the Black Rook and was protected during the Night, and so wants to at least survive the lynch as she figures she'll be dying that Night anyway.

5) She's a white piece of some sort, and is attempting to Cobbler fish (look guilty and see who jumps in to help her).

6) She's the Cobbler and wants everyone to think she's a WW pretending to be the Cobbler.

7) She has a secret role that no one knows about.

8) She is just being stupid because she had a bad day and wants to annoy everyone.

9) She was accidentally PMed by Shasta with everyone's Role, and so cannot fairly play any more, and she's just wasting time and messing around and has secretly been removed from the tally.

As you can see, the theories got a little desperate at the end. Though it's completely possible that I just made up those last couple.

I think your brains a bit fried, love. I suggest some nice ketchup (my favorite brand is Heinz) and perhaps a Mountain Dew to wash your silly theories down with. A couple of them are worth keeping though.

[the phantom]

Anyway, mister proven-Pawn here is getting sleepy. Getting ready for bed now. Might look in once more before I settle down in my square for the night.