Tol-in-Gaurhoth LVII - Chess Game for Middle Earth: Game Thread

[the phantom]

Originally Posted by Izzy

The only things I think are questionable - are her matching votes with phantom...

Well, dearie, I believe that you have voted exactly the same, so really...

[Isabellkya]

When did you think there was something funny about me in the first place Fea?

True indeed, phantom.



Edit. Fixed a typing error.

[the phantom]

The votes-

Dury +++tp
Willa +++Sally
Steve ++Sally (2)
Kath +++Hansy
Fea ++++Izzy

I can't say who I'll vote for yet. I need to see who Izzy and Brin vote for first so we can all vote the same way again.

I could vote for Sally because she annoyed me earlier, but then if she's the Cobbler I would hate to give her the satisfaction of being lynched.

I could vote for Izzy just to see if it sheds any light on yesterday's events. Problem is, it probably won't and then we'll be nowhere.

I could vote for Hansy because I'm uncomfortable with those that I can't get a read on, but since I have no read can I justify such a vote?

I'll just wait for Izzy and Brin and we'll dogpile onto someone random at the last minute. That sounds like a good plan. Or a stupid plan. But sometimes the best plans are stupid. (e.g. Let's take the Ring and walk into Mordor with it!)

EDIT: xpost Brin

[the phantom]

Originally Posted by Brin

I really want to say I don't believe you and this is just another ploy meant to confuse us, which it could be.

When I do a ploy, confusing everyone is never the primary intention. It is an unfortunate side effect that always gets me into trouble.

Originally Posted by Brin

But then I remember back to when you figured Boro out so quickly, so maybe you do have it figured out once again.

I'm glad you think that it's at least possible.

Originally Posted by Brin

Or you could just be another baddie who is full of it.

If I was a baddie, Bishy would be dead m'dear.

Sorry. That last comment was a little big-headed. Even for me.

It's true though.

[satansaloser2005]

Ah, good. My top suspect has a vote, so I may as well get the formalities out of the way.


++Hansy




Back in a bit, but want to catch up on some other internet stuff.

(And if anyone cares, youth group was AMAZING tonight. That is all.)

[Isabellkya]

I both read and skimmed Lariren.
She seems quite sensible, yet quirky. At some points she would make a theory about something; then when someone directed attention to it - she would downplay it, calling it "silly" or "horrible". She downplayed some of her theories at the start saying "naive". I don't know if it can be attributed to being a new(er?) player. I'm not sure on that part, since I've never played with her before. I recall someone saying it, though not sure who. That she "tip-toed" around; which seems to be the best word to describe her so far.

++SPM


X'd since #538

[Mnemosyne]

Originally Posted by Dury

Night. Pick a good one.

Um... don't you mean "pick an evil one"?

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Mnemosyne

Um... don't you mean "pick an evil one"?

No she means pick a good one.

[Mnemosyne]

Izzy -- I'm a bit concerned about the lack of attention Lari is getting myself, but when I read over her stuff (surprise) I don't see anything that raises major suspicion.

[Lariren Shadow]

So this is what I get for going to a club meeting, class, and then the Top Chef finale(yes I totally love that show). Now I have to catch up and there will be no long analysis here.

Originally Posted by Mnemosyne

Yeah, till Lari and I come in and both vote for you out of sheer vindictiveness.

(Er, if Lari's okay with that... if not, I can at least make it a tie...)

Hm...but I don't want to vote tp at all. I find him quiet innocent and would not want to vote him.

Originally Posted by Brinniel

And Sally...oh Sally...
She's acting funny, there's no denying that...and I can't really find much reason why she'd want to bring so much attention to herself. However, I still have the feeling that she is innocent, as insane as she is. After all, why on earth would one of the werewolves or BQ draw attention to themselves like that? And while she does seem a bit cobblerish, I also doubt that as well. Simply because the baddies have been doing quite well as it is, so there's really no reason for a Black Pawn to suddenly go suicidal. But still, what's with the odd behaviour...maybe she ate something funny. Others have mentioned she's an easy lynch, and I agree. Which is why I don't intend to vote for her toDay. Though, I still can't figure out why Sally finds me so evil. If she keeps hunting me like this, it's gonna get her nowhere.

My thoughts on her excatly. I think Sally is more innocent than not. She is bringing a lot of attention to herself, but I think she might have fallen into the same trap I did last game: I knew I was innocent and then kept getting marked as guilty and then had to make sure that I didn't die. Plus she hasn't done any song parodies yet. So clearly she is innocent.

Originally Posted by Isabellkya

I both read and skimmed Lariren.
She seems quite sensible, yet quirky. At some points she would make a theory about something; then when someone directed attention to it - she would downplay it, calling it "silly" or "horrible". She downplayed some of her theories at the start saying "naive". I don't know if it can be attributed to being a new(er?) player. I'm not sure on that part, since I've never played with her before. I recall someone saying it, though not sure who. That she "tip-toed" around; which seems to be the best word to describe her so far.

This is my third game for the record. So I'm newer, but not as new as some in the game.

I'm not going to vote Sally or tp. Sally doesn't get my vote because she looks more innocent than not, she keeps trying to say more than she should about her innocents. Tp because, well, I just don't think he's evil. From what I see in his posts he seems more innocent than not.

I have no idea about Izzy. She didn't die at Night, which leads me to think she's more guilty. But then the wolves might not have seen her as the best kill. Maybe too many wolves were involved with her almost lynch for them to be comfortable with.

I still don't feel right about Hansy. His posts have been interesting but they are rubbing me the wrong way. His post where he gives his reasons also sets off red flags to me.

So, making sure I get this in and I know I have 20 minutes about but still:

++Hansy

But toMorrow, I'm going to take a closer look at Izzy.

Edit: x-posted with Brinn and Mnemi.

[Mnemosyne]

Tie has been broken!

Thoughts?