T-I-G LV Sing when you're winning

[the phantom]

Originally Posted by Boro

And the "sneak in the first post" bit too was deliberate choice of words.

Ha ha! I forgot to point that out. That was my favorite bit.

Originally Posted by Mac

I was just going to wonder whether he was the cobbler, but that hint is too obvious (if noticed).

That's the key- if noticed. If the Critics notice, but no one on the thread says anything about it, they are more likely to think they have spotted Walter. That's one reason I never said anything about it. In addition, at first I thought it was possible that he was the Seer or a Lover attempting to shield himself from the Night-kill. But now that the final Lover has been outed, his ploy can be clearly seen for what it is, so why not point it out to everyone and allow Boro to bask in the light of his quality plotting.

I guess we can now assume that the critics know his identity (unless the cobbler didn't see the hint either). With the soulmates still out there, it's explicable why the wolves abstained from an ordo.

So, you think he's been Walter-spied already? I'm not so sure. Maybe, I guess. But it's also a strong possibility that Walter viewed me and TGWBS on the first two nights. And we must leave open the possibility that Brin was viewed the Night before she was killed, simply because a Walter-spied-Ordo is the safest possible kill for the Critics to make (because they know that person is not the Divo).