T-I-G LV Sing when you're winning

[satansaloser2005]

(Disclaimer: Yes, I know, I'm rubbish at song lyrics. And I whipped this out mighty quick, so bear with me.)

I could sniff out all the critics if I wasn't so narcissistic
Consultin' with the mod.
And my head I'd be scratchin' while
my thoughts were busy hatchin'
If I only had a bod.

I'd unravel every riddle for any individ'le,
With the itch to lynch.
With the baddies I'd be floggin'
I could be another Noggin
If I only had a bod.

Oh, I could tell you why tgwbs refused to use syntax.
I could think of things even Fea couldn't uncode.
And then I'd sit, and BS some more.

I would not be just a nothin' my head all full of stuffin'
My heart all full of pain.
I would dance and be merry, life would be a ding-a-derry,
If I only had a brain.


Aka dead men vote no reps.

[Macalaure]

Errr...

I demand a mass-modfire!!

[Boromir88]

Anyway, I was just irritated by your first analysis which suggested that Fea is not evil at all.~Mac

Understandable, I clicked on his post count and was going down post-by-post from Day 1, which the language didn't make it seem like he found a critic on Night 1. But there is no doubt that if on Night 1 he wasn't confident about Fea, than Night 2 he knew for certain, which I didn't get to yet. I wasn't considering the cobbler possibility until I read the other analysis posts, which all came out simultaneously it seemed.

That is when all the talk of Fea being tricksy and particularly his vote "She may not be critic, but she deserves it" made the most sense. I was looking solely at the critic possibility, and on Night 1 it just doesn't sound like he found a critic, but he possibly spotted Walter. Or in the very least, Fea thought tgwbs dreamt her Night 1, so checked him out the next night and then the info was dropped to the wolves. I hadn't gotten to tgwbs Day 2 posts, which I will do now.

At least, now that the Cardinalss of seemingly run away with it in their game.

[Boromir88]

As if. I wasn't asking you to take a bullet for me, I was asking you to give one. At an opportunely vindictive moment.~Fea

If I thought you were worth it, I'd still be more than glad to take the noose for you. I recall attempting that not too long ago, because I was far too big of a distraction towards the end, but that didn't work out. I made the attempt though, and if I thought you were worth it more than my own measly existance, I would do it again.

Yes, if we figured she is a Critic.~tp

There may be just that possibility. Day 2, tgwbs' language changes towards Fea...

Post 329

This make Fea seem even more critic.

Although Wild Man now thoroughly prejudice, this seem critic question to him.

Post 341

Wild Man say every game, every game none listen. Perhaps Fea critic. Perhaps Wild Man critic. Therefore, cannot trust what you say, cannot trust what Wild Man say

Now if he did spot Fea as the cobbler, and with the talk of the Cobbler's ability to spy this could be tgwbs just trying to throw Fea off. And so he changes his language by starting to call Fea a critic. Or, his vote for Fea on Day 1 was a statement of intent for his next night dream, he checks on Fea and finds she's a critic.

[Mithalwen]

Originally Posted by Macalaure

Errr...

I demand a mass-modfire!!

First, I am going to have a little drinky - and then I am going toexecute the whole bally lot... especially those whose noses are prettier than mine.

Seriously unimpressed.

[Boromir88]

If Fea is the cobbler, then we're about to do exactly what she wants us to.~Mac

Perhaps, but we need to start somewhere, and our best shot is Fea.

If she's a critic, maybe we can go in pick up other mates.
If she's the cobbler, maybe we can discern her other spies.

(And yes I realize with Fea either one of those is a crap shoot. I can't even figure her out when she says "I left you a clue, and here it is for you!").

But we got to start somewhere, and I would prefer it not be Agan, who there's really nothing on other than being paired with Fea. Which, albeit doesn't look good for a critic-Agan, but if she's innocent and is caught in an unintentional assocations? Unless you propose a double-lynch today, because whether Fea turns out critic or Walter, it won't change anything regarding Agan, and we'd essentially end up lynching her the next day anyway?

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

You really shouldn't blame Lari. She was nothing but hesitant. The others can attest to that.

[the phantom]

This is what happens when everyone gets on IM all at once.

But seriously, less than three hours to the deadline. Good luck with your decision. I shall sing at you all tomorrow.

For Fea, I'm afraid it just might be....

Past the point of no return
No backward glances
The games we've played til now are at an end
Past all thought of "if" or "when"
No use resisting
Abandon thought and let the dream descend . . .

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Unless she counts the mass Legate vote (which it doesn't look like she will).

It's certainly a moment to go in the werewolf history books.

[Aganzir]

Sorry Mith. Won't do it again. I can't deny it was fun though.

Originally Posted by Mac

I'm not buying that, I'm afraid. It would have been a sloppy analysis if it paid no attention to this fact, but the rest of your analysis was not sloppy at all, so I suspect intent.

I can repeat it after the game.
Besides if an analysis is otherwise good, does it mean there can't be any sloppy bits?

Originally Posted by Mac

On Aganzir suspecting Fea before: It could be (and is likely, I'd say) that Fea is the cobbler and Aganzir a critic, so that does not prove the innocence of either. Not to mention the critic-on-critic possibility.

I wasn't trying to prove my innocence with it, I was commenting on your post saying I started to suspect Fea only now to save my skin.

I agree with Boro about lynching Fea, especially if the other candidate is me. I'm gradually getting more afraid also of him though.

I'll try if I can come up with something regarding Mac before deadline.

edit: xed with two Feas, Kath & Mac