Werewolf LIII: The Republic

[Gwathagor]

Originally Posted by Kath

Now there are a few questions or at least things you could answer in there I think. Such as telling us whether or not there was any other support for lynching you Day 1. Re-explaining why you thought Nog innocent Day 2 because I really didn't understand that. Why, having suggested that Boro might be a wolf, you then went and voted him Rep. Why you said you'd come back and interact with people so that we could get a better view of you and then kinda didn't. Why you seemed convinced that there would be a toMorrow if sally was lynched instead of you. There may be some other things, it's up to you if you want to do a really comprehensive defense or just basically answer the questions.

Green and Lommy both echoed Nogrod's suspicion of me on Day 1. Aganzir thought they were grasping at straws. Nogrod repeated his suspicions once or twice until he voted me. Phantom said he wasn't going to vote for me, among other people. Ilya said she wasn't suspicious of me. Boromir did not think my vote for Nogrod was as suspicious as Nog had made it seem and could think of no reason to vote me. Brinniel had no clear opinion of me. Conclusion: Nogrod was not alone in his suspicion of me, but neither was there a bandwagon forming. It was somewhere in between.

I thought Nogrod was innocent because it seemed to me that, once in power, a wolf would try to maintain and please those supporters who had made him a rep in the first place. Obviously I was wrong. Phantom said that he thought that it might be true of some players, but not Nog.

I did not suggest or argue that Boro was a wolf; as part of an argument to make a different point, I pointed out that it was a theoretical possibility. I eventually voted him because he seemed reasonable and fair.

I failed to post as much as I said I would (for which I apologize), because I ended up being busier than I had expected. As I've said, I'm directing a play.

I can't explain why I had it stuck in my mind that there would be a toDay, but it never even ocurred to me that we might win yesterDay. It may have had to do with the fact that sally's attitude in the face of her imminent death seemed very innocent, and that I was more than a little worried about getting lynched myself, so that I didn't think about it thoroughly.