Tol-in-Gaurhoth LII: Star Crossed II: Together for Eternity

[Brinniel]

Originally Posted by Gwath

What's the Guardian?

I think that's the hunter. Which makes her claim even more ridiculous since the whole point of the hunter is to get killed so that they can take a wolf (or in this case, lovers) down with them. Revealing the role defeats its whole purpose. Which is why I think she's lying. Anyway, I doubt there's even a hunter...with two lovers dying in one blow, I don't think Di would see it necessary to put that role in. And along with role that Fea claims to have? If Di wanted a slaughterhouse, she would've put more lovers in the game.

Eomer's reaction to all this may help tell us whether he's a baddie or not (key word: baddie...not necessarily lover).

Originally Posted by Gollum

In short, I don't know what to say about just about anybody.

If you really have no clue, I recommend reviewing posts from previous Days in more depth. You've been pretty vague so far and it'd be more helpful for us to hear some stronger opinions than "I don't know."

EDIT: X-ed with Fea...okay, apparently I was wrong. But I swear in Volo's game the Guardian was the hunter.