Let's cast the Silmarillion

[Thinlómien]

Originally Posted by A Little Green

Joaquin Phoenix as well as Rufus Sewell certainly deserve roles.

Yes - why do I see them as sons of Fëanor? Also, you could add Jake Gyllenhaal as a third brother, he has - or could have - similar appearance and presence. But it just might make the movie too glittery, I don't know.

Originally Posted by Greenie

Also, I googled Olivia Hussey (someone suggested her as Lúthien), found a pic of her when she's older, and instantly thought about Melian. Take a few years away, and it's perfect. (I don't know about her acting skills though - I've never seen her in any film...)

Hey, that's a good suggestion.

Originally Posted by skip spence

Ándrog Mads Mikkelsen

Hey now that's a creepy suggestion. Excellent, actually.