Tol-in-Gaurhoth XLVII: Dueling Wizards Werewolf II

[Brinniel]

Originally Posted by Izzy

Going into Night 4 we had a Seer and a Hunter, in terms of gifteds.
since Mac our Ranger was killed Night 3, a new one could not of been scried until last Night (Night 4.)
Since there was only one kill last night, logically it means that the EW did not scry a new wolf to their team. Rather, they scried either the GW or the Hunter. Since they chose to kill the Seer, they obviously did not scry her.
If they had scried the new Ranger, we would've known about it. Both wizards scrying the same person during the night = death from too much magic. Which leaves the Hunter and GW. Why choose a shot in the dark with trying to scry the GW whom they may not know, when they have a supposed hunter out in plain view?

Ehm Izzy, you're forgetting that it could also go the other way around.

Another reason there may be only three wolves could be because either the GW scryed a gifted or the EW. Also, even though the ranger would've been scryed only last Night (if we have one), they can still use that gift the same Night. Though I do doubt the ranger successfully protected...I think it would've been mentioned in the narration.