MIddlearth, OZ and faithfulness

[Finduilas]

Originally Posted by Sauron the White

Oz was a very loved and successful series of books that were very well known before the film was put to screen. As far as the "greatest" who knows and who can say? Not I.

I've read The Wizard of Oz. I personally prefered the book to the movie, but then, there are very few book/movie combinations that I couldn't say that about. Reason I don't complain is, why should I? No one is telling me that who ever made the movie had a right to do what ever he pleased. No one is trying to tell me it couldn't have been better. And, Wizard of Oz isn't among my top ten favorite books. Why? It wasn't that great.