Or no Hobbits at all...

[Galin]

I think the thread as it stands shows that I meant I wanted to keep the topic in context (for my part anyway).

The context here is not as narrow as you want to keep it. As the moderators have explained over and over in many threads, discussion of the work of JRRT and the movies that flow for that work is on topic regardless of the ebb and flow of how a thread evolves.

I said feel free to enlarge the context as you like -- just try and do it in a way that does not misrepresent my argument please.

Lets get back to the thread topic of no more hobbits if we can.

I'm all for that