WW XXXX - The scouring of the Shire, vol.2 - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Brinniel · 12-02-2007, 08:02 AM

Analysis of Menel:

Day 1

#17: Agrees there's 1-2 quiet wolves. Thinks there will be one wolf who will confuse everyone.

#122: Thinks morm is acting odd. Doesn't like that his reason for voting Valier is because she might get him lynched. Doesn't think Valier is a wolf if morm is. Votes morm.

Day 2

#148: Doesn't think morm would kill Valier, but it could be a double bluff.

#152: Nerwen's wolfish behaviour was actually newbiness. One wolf probably voted her.

I think possibly more than one wolf voted her.

#158: Agrees with Farael that Rikae is suspicious. Thinks it's possible morm and Rikae are wolves together.

Conclusion: Menel seems to quickly jump the bandwagon. First with morm, then with Rikae. Also, I agree with others' comments about him stating that he's surprised to be alive and so on. I've overlooked it because I know he'd been dying early on a lot. But letting everyone know that is a perfect way for a wolf to slide by..

12-02-2007, 08:02 AM	#11
Brinniel Reflection of Darkness Join Date: Jun 2002 Location: Polishing the stars. Well, somebody has to do it; they're looking a little bit dull. Posts: 2,983	Analysis of Menel: Day 1 #17: Agrees there's 1-2 quiet wolves. Thinks there will be one wolf who will confuse everyone. #122: Thinks morm is acting odd. Doesn't like that his reason for voting Valier is because she might get him lynched. Doesn't think Valier is a wolf if morm is. Votes morm. Day 2 #148: Doesn't think morm would kill Valier, but it could be a double bluff. #152: Nerwen's wolfish behaviour was actually newbiness. One wolf probably voted her. I think possibly more than one wolf voted her. #158: Agrees with Farael that Rikae is suspicious. Thinks it's possible morm and Rikae are wolves together. Conclusion: Menel seems to quickly jump the bandwagon. First with morm, then with Rikae. Also, I agree with others' comments about him stating that he's surprised to be alive and so on. I've overlooked it because I know he'd been dying early on a lot. But letting everyone know that is a perfect way for a wolf to slide by.. __________________ Nolite te bastardes carborundorum